Mentioned on the other thread about Laybutt but there are a couple of forwards in that side that I wouldn’t mind in our pack next year

Laybutt’s defence was outstanding, really put it about.

It’s a strange this is the World Cup. Fifita looked too bulky and his main contribution was to lose the ball after 50 minutes of anticipation.

There were certainly some forwards with punch in that game for both teams.

To ga’s 12 was excellent and was busting tackles all night.

That 6 for Tonga was pretty good too.

I think PNG were robbed there. Good game though. Enjoyed it.

I wonder if Cheater would take Hood back and give us Ipape

Think your right about Fifita. World at his feet when he burst through at Brisbane. Had the big money move to Gold Coast and he’s been a bit laboured ever since. Still quite young in RL terms so hopefully will come again. Forward arm wrestle was great to watch though

Like the Andrew Voss and James Graham combo in the commentary box as well. Refreshing

I’m with you there PT, that disallowed try by Video ref just after half time was a poor call, and that last Tonga try I thought in the build up, there was a knock on and a Tonga player picks the ball up in an offside position to score the try. Just my opinion of course.

interesting call

rebounding from the bottom of the corner flag is not the intention of the law I think... I think if the ball carrying arm hits the post it should be called out of play.

But that isn't the rule.

I disagree. The corner flag rule being binned has led to some fantastic tries over the years. It was a more unusual effect last night but Tom Johnstone wouldn't have been half as effective if the corner flag rule was still there.

I think it was a try but it went up as no try. Was it so obvious that it could be overruled? Probably. I can understand why Thaler felt there was a possibility some of the ball was on the line, so not able to overturn the no try, but I'm not sure anyone would have complained had he done so.

Great game though. Don't think Tonga looked great though. They are going to have to improve to win it, because the winner of the Tonga-v-Samoa quarter final will be the team that get its act together first.

You misinterpret me… I like the rule… but when the ball carrying arm or ball hits the corner flag before grounding … I think no it should be called out