He does a lot of good things, he just needs to back himself finishing in the corner.

Saving a big performance for Wednesday

Don't want to disrespect tryers but effort alone is nowhere near enough. If it was I'd be a professional golfer!

All their second half tries came down our left side and to me it looked to be Bill who was frequently out of position leaving Kaye exposed again. Didn't he do that a few weeks ago too ??

Your right he does hesitate at times but was far from the worst player for us tonight , but that hopefully would come with more game time and confidence ,but that looks to have run out again as Tom should be back .

Bill shoots out of the line so often however it’s a problem we’ve had right back to the Vince Mellars days. Leaves the winger looking poor in defence when there’s not much they can actually do.

At least twice he came out of the line and missed the tackle ....

That unforced error by Lino really took the game away from us.

At least Salford are getting stuffed ....and Pauli Pauli has just been sent off !!!!

Not the best night Fil for quite a few players ,our edge defence was targeted numerous times to good effect .Thought our attack was too much one up ,as when we threw the ball about we made good yards and caused problems . Wires were too fast and too strong over most of the park

Not good signs for Wednesday. Defence was crap last week too.

Not sure it`s quite as simple as that old boy, its all about numbers, all about what your inside man is doing, you can`t just pin in on one player without looking at individual scenarios as they happen, I am sure Bill does get it wrong but there is obviously a reason he comes in and commits to a man and I don`t think he is particularly any worse for it than Lyne or Arundel.