I was on here when you played Hemel, I came to watch and thought Maskill deserved his shot - and there's no better time than this.

I'm sure he will give Dickie Agar some selection issues for whenn Aiton is fit (assuming he isn't)

Bearng in mind you're only playing against us - we can't win an each way bet on the boat race.

No doubt we will score 26ish points, that will happen, but you yourselves will score 6/7/8 tries yourselves quite easily.

Worrying about playing Cas tells me all I need to know about your top 8 aspirations

....Cas are trying to make the eight though. As in, eight points for the season...

It's not that Cockayne couldn't give it a go he probably would but it's the wrong answer and not guaranteed to be the right one. My main argument is he is in the England train on squad as a Winger because thats what he is really good at - why take a player who is so good at that position and play him somewhere else where he may or may not work. I know why people like the idea because he is a busy player who makes lots of yard from the ruck - however a good amount of that is out wide whilst at hooker it's all up the middle. Also I've seen nothing to suggest he is a distributer of the ball.

I think you're right, if there was no genuine hooker available then maybe but it would lose us so much out wide it would negate the value for me.

haha, I agree with your post vasty but this made me chuckle - as well as confused

I know what I meant

Yeah I'm sure you did Vasty..... you knew it was wrong, but it wasn't guaranteed to be right either

but yes, if fit, Maskill would be my choice. To be honest, when you beat us down Cas, Aiton didn't really have a good game.

"the smiths" and cockayne stood out that day

As i said a total gamble.

Our season is sinking quicker than the titanic and too often we dont look at all fired up for a battle..........take Salford and HKR as prime examples.
When Cockayne played a more central/pivotal role he tended to "aggravate/wind up" the opposition.
His scoots would make good yardage,something we dont see from Aiton.
I think we should be looking for something that could change the way we are shaping up and offer a different dimension to what Aiton brings.

Aiton trained today, he as apointment this week with the doc, we have to wait and see

If we didn't have Aiton in the middle tackling like a machine we'd probably be conceding a greater points average. He is one of the top tacklers in Super League at present.

Sorry to disagree BUT we have seen Aiton doing a lot more "scoots" this season.

This^^^
He has looked far more like an international, nrl level hooker this season.
We need him back if fit.

Aiton is a boss and we are weaker without him unless some of the other guys step it up considerably.