Maybe another reason why we need some cover in the pivots.

A good one would be someone who can capably fill 6, 7 and 9.

For me it was worthy of a penalty and nothing else.

Think after the tackle, they replayed it, Eddie stuck his two penneth in and asked Stuart Cummings what he thought?
'Nuff Said!

Twice he was penalised the whole match and if you've seen the clip, how as a RL player when your making as many tackles as he is are you going to constantly avoid a tackle over the shoulder & a tackle we see every game without any punishment,

Yes he could do with cleaning up his game slightly but it's just my opinion, if you take that bit of mongrel out of him I don't think you'd have as effective of player. He likes to throw himself around and put hits on people, which is what you want from a player like him, when they're making 30-40 a game.
Also to say he's becoming a liability we cannot afford to carry because he was injured is a bit wrong, injuries are part of the game and it's not as if he's got a history of it. Yes you added suspensions as well but lets be right some of those can be debated/borderline and he seems to be getting suspensions on reputation alone. We had the gouging one, which obviously formed the majority, that I don't think no ones ever seen any evidence of. The same match he got one for a high tackle on Ah Van that imo was a perfectly good hit across the chest and now we have this latest one.

Can't believe he actually plead guilty to it. That's what we're doing wrong, not playing the disciplinary game right off the field. But seriously once he'd been given the grading , I don't think CC would want to risk him going not guilty because chances are they'd have given him longer and missed the CC semi.

I would suspect it does Scott and the club good for him to sit out the Cas match.. In comparison to the semi it's a nothing game with only bragging rights at stake. I'm sure the MRP are doing a frame by frame check on the Catalan game just to see if they can nail Scott for something else. Fortunately the Catalans coach has a lot more class than moaning Denis Betts.

We need Scott Moore at his most aggressive and energetic best for the Wire game. He'll have a few games cushion then before Wembley, should he be raked in again for sneezing on someone.

Remember that he pleaded guilty. The disciplinary needs sorting out, its not difficult, get rid of ex players on the panel, get rid of early plea, past record, no legal representatives, all we need is consistency.
If you think we are hard done by have a look at what players from Div 1 and the champ get in comparison to SL players.
The SOL 1 one match ban was an utter disgrace, that said it takes a poor decision like that for the game as a whole to sit up and notice how flawed the system is : an ill wind and all that

Agreed, it could be a blessing.

We have a fair chance of beating Cas without Moore. We have little chance of beating Warrington without him IMHO.

It's all about priorities now.

I'm fairly happy for Moore to sit the Cas game out and be raring to go in the semi final.

Yes, I am happy for that to happen.

If we had really good cover at 9, should we get to Wembley, I would wrap him in cotton wool throughout super 8's. Sio is good, but I see him more as a back rower, and like him at 13

Yes, I am happy for that to happen.

If we had really good cover at 9, should we get to Wembley, I would wrap him in cotton wool throughout super 8's. Sio is good, but I see him more as a back rower, and like him at 13

www.rugby-league.com/article/380 ... l-decision Unfeking believeable don't plead guilty , fight the ban on the tackle that could end someone's career and get your ban REDUCED....words fail me

www.rugby-league.com/article/380 ... l-decision Unfeking believeable don't plead guilty , fight the ban on the tackle that could end someone's career and get your ban REDUCED....words fail me

I don't see how anyone can defend the RFL - inept, amateur and weak.

We should have appealed and should the worst scenario happen prior to semi and another of our players have been duped by Cobb this weekend, if we have a valid point I cenrtainly would.

MRP are unbelievable and really think strongly about having ex players on the panel and several from Wigan is not a good thing.

Should be ex police or solicitor who has an understanding of the sport

Norman Cooper?