Needs to learn how to put a winger away.

Second game in a row then but nice to see honesty from the opposition.
As long as we learn from these games there may yet be hope.

match highlights bit.ly/1GT7WtM

match highlights bit.ly/1GT7WtM

Looking at that, Lyne's double movement decision was a bit harsh. He wasn't tackled when he hit the ground first time. For me he could have just rolled over, and at worst just a play the ball.
With the ref right in front of him and him lifting his arm, I can see why he gave the decision but on the camera view on there I wouldn't have given double movement.

rlI'd disagree.rl


Huaraki tries to hand-off Ryan, looks like he's not strong enough to keep him away though and his arm folds in, unfortunately with Ryan's neck heading straight for his forearm/elbow. Looks like there's nothing in it to me and it's just unlucky for Ryan when there was obviously a lot of force going either way.

Everything else you said was spot on though.

Well in future that'll teach Ryan not to attack a players elbow with his throat!

I can't view whatever you've linked to but I'm guessing it's a still image showing what you think is a player laying on top of Lyne therefore completing the tackle.
However if that's the case it's irrelevant, watch the play at normal speed and you see the defender sliding straight off Lyne in one motion which doesn't constitute a completed tackle

I was really impressed with you lot yesterday, you could of won the game in the first 20 minutes if you took your chances. I thought Hall was your best player on the pitch, he made great yards even when he was under pressure. Smith didn't do much apart from the drop out kick in the second half and after watching the saints game i thought Lyn was going to destroy us on the wing. I can see you lot surprising a lot of teams especially at home this year. Good luck apart for rest of the season

Lyne was never stopped and momentum forward was continuous never the less he still looked to be short and probably knocked on from the highlights

The ref may have been too quick on his whistle (and sometimes not at all given some holding down) but we wee our worse enemy too many simple errors and too much sily play trying to score off every ball, until that changes we won't win many, although I do think there will be a game where it will all click and forward passes won't be forward and passes will stick, lets just hope it's sooner rather than later!

And what about the other frames where he doesn't have a hand on him and Lyne is a couple of yards closer to the line? The 'tackling' player ends up behind the line when lynes momentum is halted. IMO it doesn't matter as I'm still not convinced he actually got the ball on or over the line

About the Huaraki-Ryan incident, it's just onf of those unfortunate things that happen. Huaraki din't lead with his elbow. If a tackler is off slightly and gets a knee in the face from someone running normally, is it a penalty to the defending team? Of course not. Nobody wants to see stuff like that, but it hapens from time to time.

Sorry about the link, yes that's what it's suppoed to be though. Taylor never loses contact once he's made the tackle though in real-time or otherwise. And frankly, he doesn't get the ball down on/over the line anyway!

Wakey had ample opportunities to take a more commanding lead in the first 10-15 minutes yesterday, had they taken them it may have been a very different outcome.

That's true about taylor not having a hand on him, he is still laid on top of him though. My understanding of the rules may be a little off there, is a hand required to be on the player for a tackle to be completed?

I probably wouldn't have argued with the ref giving play on in all fairness. It looks more of a double-movement than a try though if I had to pick one of those two options.

As a wakey fan I disagree and thought Lyne was tackled. I thought he looked tackled at the game [i was in the salford end behind where he scores] and I think he looks tackled on the video.

Quote: andyh0064 " I beg to differ, Taylor clearly slides straight over Lyne whilst Lyne is still in motion bit.ly/1GT7WtM

Quote: andyh0064 " I beg to differ, Taylor clearly slides straight over Lyne whilst Lyne is still in motion bit.ly/1GT7WtM

Hard to argue with that as a double movement - and he gives himself away by reaching out; if the tackler had fallen away, he should have got up and run over the line, or at least rolled and placed the ball down. Result = try.

A bit of white line fever from Reece, resulting in a decision that most RL fans would agree with.