Happy to listen again. If you have it post the link.

But I'm not sure what you want me to say. Whether someone told him or not, based on the published rules it was incorrect.
No amount of 'if you think you know' will change that.

If we'd been working to those interpretations we'd have come unstuck at submission time.

But it's all done now. The info has been clarified and he (and you) should now know.

Doesn't stop me being concerned that he didn't know. I'm allowed to do that I think.

I did register to it.
He is clearly doing loads of things to improve the IMG score and I think he even lowballs the number we'll get to.
But he does get the date bit wrong.

And I didn't point it out. Luppy used it as a reason why I might be wrong when I said it will be after the grand final.

Can you point me to where the date is noted in the handbook please?

I can't see any reference to the announcement date and a firm date was only revealed in this last week.

It doesn't.
But it does say the grand final points are included in the final number. So the date couldn't have been before then.

So it's not even mentioned in the handbook - I knew I couldn't find it.

There can only be 2 teams in the GF - you therefore know a minimum and a maximum possible score, so a decision "could" have been announced before the GF.

It's far more logical just to wait for certainty though.

That was announced in the last few days, long after the Ellis interview.

Why would they announce it before all the points are gathered?

And it doesn't just affect the two in the GF. The final positions that affect all team points are calculated from the final positions in the playoffs.

I'm really not sure what you are trying to prove.

Someone asked when the date was for the announcement
I said I don't know but it can't be before the grand final
Luppy questioned that because Ellis said something different
RFL announce date is after grand final.
Ellis wasn't correct but now knows.

Giants knew. "Membership of the Betfred Super League in 2025 will be determined by the top 12 teams in the 2024 rankings, which will be announced at the culmination of the 2024 season." Published 25th Oct 2023 https://www.giantsrl.com/article/8626/r ... ng-results

Giants knew. "Membership of the Betfred Super League in 2025 will be determined by the top 12 teams in the 2024 rankings, which will be announced at the culmination of the 2024 season." Published 25th Oct 2023 https://www.giantsrl.com/article/8626/r ... ng-results

Warrington Guardian used the same wording so I assume given by an RFL release. https://www.warringtonguardian.co.uk/sp ... -gradings/

Warrington Guardian used the same wording so I assume given by an RFL release. https://www.warringtonguardian.co.uk/sp ... -gradings/

I said it's logical to await the conclusion of the season.

However, the only 2 clubs it affects are the clubs in the GF - all other scores are done and dusted by then. Their scores can only be affected by +/- 0.1111

IMG had previously suggested scores "as early as possible", so I don't get this idea that Ellis was "wrong", and certainly not "cringey". Have I misunderstood what was meant by that?

The date was only announced this week. Clubs clearly had not been given this detail when Ellis did the March interview.

That's not the kind of thing he would get wrong.

As I've posted above, other clubs posted that they knew it was announced at the culmination of the season.
What I found cringe is that he said it means the playoffs don't matter.
He should have just said he didn't know and left it at that.
Again I'm not having a go at him. This is 1 in hundreds of things he's got right.
But to me, and it's only me, if you think the final scores are coming out before the playoffs, you didn't read the handbook properly.
If I get it wrong no one really cares. If he gets it wrong it matters a lot.

I didn't hear that he'd said that.

On the second point, the handbook makes no reference at all as to when scores will be revealed - none at all, so that point is nonsensical.

It says the Final league positions after grand final and the Grand Final bonus points are part of the calculation.

I can't explain it any better than that.

But again, I've found two clubs that announced it would be after season finishes back in October.

Still not sure why you are arguing a point that is already proved to be right.

For what it’s worth; Martin Jepson was interviewed on the COYF cast recently & was a little ambiguous regarding some IMG points/processes etc & I just put it down to him playing his cards close to his chest rather than being wrong or “not being all over it” & I’d say the same for Matt Ellis. It serves them no purpose to be wholly transparent & in some instances could be quite damaging.

All the details of this years omg are in this current weeks league express, final release of points issued KS circa 23rd to 26/27 th October !

From what i remember reading, the final scores by IMG will be totted up after the seasons finishes, including the championship play off final. IMG scores will then be checked by the RFL ,and then an independent audit of the scores by an outside auditor.
Hopefully,all three i.e. IMG,RFL and the independent audit will all agree on final points tally that will give a definitive score for each club without clubs having to appeal.
Anyway that's my take on it.