Has any one seen him play?

personally no, some have but very little, but he comes on good recommendation.
have you, how do you rate him?

NO, we are hoping and praying that he's not a dud.

and still building him up to be the new messiah before we start ripping him to bits for only being a decent player and not the superstar we led ourselves to believe he was without ever seeing him play.

A lot of good judges reckon he's the real deal, just got to remember it will take him time to adapt to a whole new way of life.

Yeah i've seen him play. He is young, clearly has talent, seems keen to organise, has a good kicking game, is good enough to have played in the NRL at a relatively tender age, and comes with a glowing recommendation from more than a few highly respected ex pros. However, positive comments aside, I Won't judge him on the evidence of an extended highlights reel. Millard being the prime example of why you shouldn't do that. Until he is here in the Red White and Blue, and has played more than a handful of games it's not fair to label the kid. A partnership with Smith won't happen overnight, but the potential is there for sure.

Thousands

Same.

A point on Millard though - let's not forget that he became significantly more 'Magic' when he moved to Catalans. Further proof that this is a team game - good players need quality around them to be able to shine.

Came on the recommendation of Hull scouts (who've been tracking him for 18 months), Henry Paul & Monty Betham.

Any of those recommendations would be good enough for me, but to have such recommendations from people in Europe & New Zealand is impressive to say the least.

I've been chatting with him for a month or so now & he seems a very "switched on" lad, who shows great hunger to succeed, IMO it's a good thing we have him for 3 years!

I don't want anyone to think I'm billing this guy up (although I have been known to end my tweets with #eclipsechase- just banter with him really) but all I will stress is we have very much the raw materials of a VERY good player here!
What we have to do now is assist him with him transition (club & fans) & condition/mold this talent into SL gold.

Not sure how many of you remember Henry Paul's year at BV, but IMO that is the type of player, in terms of potential & where he's at now as a player, we are dealing with. Exciting times ahead- if he fulfills on his potential.

Welcome aboard Isaac, I've got a feeling your going to be very successful here.

why would anyone seek the opinon of monty betham? the bloke was a complete liaiblity in trinity colours.

Wash your mouth out!

Monty is a legend, best 13 I've seen in my 23 years of supporting Trin.

just be sure not to boo him off 70 minutes into his debut like we did with a certain unknown overseas player nearly 4 years ago!

Wonder if you'll do that with Sika Manu

Nearly died when I heard that "tall tale" this morning.