Quote vastman="vastman"I'd agree, but absolute negativity simply never works.'"
He's only suggesting resting Ali cos I told him!
I think there's a mixture of views here that are right on different counts.
Yesterdays loss was set up on Sunday - I haven't watched the Bulls/Cas game, but I doubt very much it would come even close to this intensity of ours at Salford - that was as tough as it gets physically. Add to that the want/need to introduce our new 'star' signing and it ends up in a buggers muddle - most of it not in anyones control!
However, I have to say that there are some things we could have done better IMO, such as using Matty Wildie, Briscoe and even Trout to try and keep things fresh and, whilst he made an almighty boo-boo, I think Agar seemed very unfair on Walshaw who played well on Sunday, with the net result being that we were effectively a man down for most of the match!
On the Ali thing - as well as keeping him fresh for our 'big' games, I want to see our players try and play without being able to just 'give it to Ali'. We used to do the same with Solo and it doesn't work every time. In the 2 games we've played, in both second halves, we have not used Collis hardly at all. We are blessed in having such quality on our right side attack and we need to use it better.
Finally, and this is related to the Walshaw issue, are we trying to kill Kirmo. He gives his all, and more, but he is not super-human and he needs to come off when he is knackered.
So, some issues with coaching, but not enough to throw baby out with the bathwater - we just need to be a bit smarter in the circumstances. Timing etc will come and there is plenty of good football in this squad.