Not at all, it's called a forum int it, people have different opinions. I think hall could make a very good winger gives us another option on the last play kick with him been tall which we have not had for a long time. Would of said Young Johnston but as seen at hull and cas game, we saw the best and worst of him and with the Middle 8's coming up unfortunately for me I don't think we can afford to risk him.
Plus I wouldn't play Riley as shown from yesterday don't have that killer instinct.
I would of had Owen there but obviously we can't, so for me hall would be the next best option

Take Dan Smith out, he's off to Huddersfield. You have got Anthony Mullally on loan for the rest of the season though before he joins Leeds.

Yes, how dare he score 4 tries. Drop him.

Locke
Johnstone
Arundal
Tansey
lyne
Godinet
Miller
Scruton
Sio
D Smith/Mullalley
Molloy
Ashurst
Washbrook

McShane
Simon
Anderson
Lauititi

Not seen enough of some of the newbies yet, so might change my mind. Certainly lots of good options in the pack, but still look woefully short on centre options.

My question is why would we play any of the top 17 In the 2 reaming games? they mean absolutely nothing and all we are doing is risking injury by playing them- play our under 19;s I say.

That's not going to help our first team learn to play under our new coaches style, or give them much of a confidence boost going into the 8s.

I think I would play the likes of Johnstone, Crowther and Jowitt though in the remaining games and the 8s. The only way they are going to get better is by playing.

Anybody who does not include Anakin in the 17 needs banning for RL as they know nothing.

and you've been out in the sun too long

Sorry, Belly, we all had hopes for Annakin but he has had a couple of occasions where either being run over in defence or brain explosions have cost us.
BS is a font of knowledge, probably forgotten more than most of us have ever known, and removed him quickly last time out.
I hope he makes it though. I suspect we are forming the biggest pack possible to run over the Championship sides. Annakin does not fit that bracket.

I'm sure even Jon Snow would disagree with you.

Think Hall shouldn't be anywhere near the 17 for the middle 8's.

Johnstone is our best winger and must be in the 17.

Kirke should be given the opportunity over the next 2 games to show what he is capable of as he did briefly against Halifax in the CC. If BS can get the best out of Miller then hopefully he can with players like Kirke, Mullally, Anderson, Ashurst and Kavanagh.

very good

Pretty sure that anakin will figure in the middle 8s and will probably do a good job, but he is definitely not a shoe in considering the options we have in the back row. On his day he would definitely be in there but needs to find that level of consistency and cut out the errors. So for me Molloy would have the edge as he has been very solid this season.

Looking at the team we are likely to be putting out in the 8s . We will be going in with a very lightly used team with a pack full of players with less than a dozen games under their belt this season. Hopefully this will prove a big benefit playing against some already battered and patched up teams that have been chasing the top 8.