I wouldn't, there is always the risk you could ask for the bottle back in a reverse swap.

Danny Brough for Murphy and Lee and if they dont like it then beggar off

I'd be pushing for

Murphy and Lee for Mason, Kirmond .. That's a prop we need there and Kirmond to interchange.

Would be a good deal for both.

I'd be pushing for Murphy is not for sale

Was thinking about Murphy. He is good but not ripping it up. His strength is defence really.

If we can get a decent deal then so be it.

iknow sometimes you are a bit off the wal mate but i think broadly you have got this one right. the player you already have has far more potential than what they are offering. danny is a good player and a great bloke. kyle you don't need and andy raleigh , although i don't know him , you have already got better players than him at the club who would do a better job . in all don't think it is a good deal for wakey.just looks like hudds having a clear out.

I think you are seriously over egging Murphy as a player.

For me the biggest issue here is not what we are getting out of it but what are Hudds getting. I can't see where he fits in their plans at all. For us he is a very good player but for them he's an average signing.

The reason I want to keep Murphy is to make a stand. So that when the next really great player like a Gareth Ellis comes along people will think twice. Murphy the player I can take or leave in fact IMO George was a bigger loss.

And under egging Raleigh.

Most of his career with us he's had to defend, the ability he's shown on the front foot has been quite good, in a better attacking team like we will have next season will prove if he's got what it takes or not.

Murphys three tries (one of which was against donny) in 22 appearances this season is testament to his lack of attacking spark. Yes we've been on the back foot for a lot of the season but George, Dean, Morton etc all crossed the line more than him. But he is defensively sound, has always given 100% and has improvement in him. IF the deal is right then i'm happy for him to go. But it has to be a good deal FOR US.

He (Murphy) scored some cracking tries when he played on the wing. Hull KR away springs to mind when he went down the touchline and fended about 3 defenders off.

i like murphy, but he never will become a world beater. i think he will be a great club player where ever he ends up. but even physical freaks like atkins cant do it at international level, seeing him getting piggy backed down field by kenny-dowell was embarrasing.

These players have been feeding off scraps due to the lack of skill from our half backs, Dean and Morton are not good examples to put up against Murphy. Murphy is far better.

If Murphy is to go it should be a cash deal only the money can then be banked and when a player the club wants that cash is there.Lets not forget if they buy Murphy they will have to off load some players we can then go back and say WE are interested in.It also lets the club have the chance to look at players from other clubs who could become surplus due to new coaches coming in or for other reasons.