Not arguing, different interpretations, you and a few others seem to be talking about players who are legends in the game. For me a club legend at a club as prestigious as ours the bar should be set very high IMHO.

You are on your own with this one Vasty.
If you want to differentiate between a legend of the game and a legend at Belle Vue then so be it, but Ray Price is a legend

And now I've been drawn in too.

This thread is about tacklers.

Pound for pound, Billy Conway was pretty good, just not as memorable as some others

I think if you read the thread again I'm not, see Spookdownunder post. Nor is this forum representative of the whole supporter base either.

All I will contribute to this debate is my avatar, 46 years of watching Trin and total agreement about Ray Price, Toppo and Wally. Lewis. RL legends all of them and gave me memories that will last a lifetime.

Brian Briggs best tackler I have seen by a long way.

Jeez man, so did I. I said he was a legend for Australia and Parramatta not Trinity. I wouldn't mind if I didn't make it clear but I did, it was the same with JD. It's like you and a few others on here want to be offended.

Of course he's a RL legend without question, but a Trinity legend at 35 and one season, that is very much open to debate which is what a forum is for is it not?

In the hope of resolving this;The dictionary definition of legend is: one who is renowned for outstanding deeds or qualities whether real or fictitious.
So it can be one game or one year or a lifetime as there is no timescales

Back on thread and its Trevor Skerret for me

Brad Waugh for me tough tackling Aussie prop

Must have started watching the club about the same time and 100% agree with you, every one of them a rugby league legend in their own right. We may have only have had wally lewis and ray price for short spells but there ability, professionalism and talent were second to none. Used to remember Ray facing back to catch the ball if it hit the uprights, wally when he came back out with the turban at halifax, david topliss good friend and a great player.

Some of the better memories of the club over the years.

Club wise paul mcdermott, worlds most unlucky player missing out at wembley, dick jazievic was really tough , nigel bell and richard slater were great clubmen and home grown talents. Graham idle had to be the best off all of these great tackles and the sheer volume of them over a long period of time


It is funny though as an amateur only player I used to look at some of the pros and think they weren't all that - until i did my coaching course with stuart smith - who i d always though wasn't all that, in a training game he just about broke me in two ....

Brad Waugh was a real tough tackler more recently Washbrook also agree with Graham Idle god did he get through some graft and not just defending there are plenty more that have not been mentioned. My Dad always says for a winger Booker says they didn't want to be tackled by him many times

I've just had a quick look through the list of players and I'm not sure we've ever really had the enforcer type of player that would strike fear in to an attacker since the Turner days.

Brad Waugh, James Stosic, Adam Watene were all tough tackling blokes who could shake you up up but not really renowned for it. Certainly Trevor Skerrett was a top tacker and probably the best I've seen and I think Ellis is the most recent who stands out for me but not like an Adrian Morley or Andy Platt or Kurt Sorensen who would smash you if they could get to you.
I'd like our front row to have some of that in them this season.
We have had plenty of the workers who will run you down and they are important but sometimes I'd like the opposition to feel a bit intimidated when they take the ball in, not just disappointed because we got across to tackle them.

DON METCALF WAS A GOOD TACKLER,I REMEMBER A PERIOD IN THE LATE 60,S WHEN WE WENT QUITE A FEW GAMES WITHOUT A TRY BEING SCORED,CAN,T REMEMBER HOW MANY