Quote: TRB "I forgot the most pertinent one - Shane McNally.
Shane did well by us and got us our first play-off games, but the following season he seemed to be over-thinking things and it all got away from him. Despite his tremendous efforts, the board at the time felt that we needed to rake action and we brought Tony Smith into the hot-seat. Now Tony wasn't great, but him coming in won us 3 games we probably wouldn't have. How good would 3 wins look now?'"
Well now, this proves my point perfectly.
I quite liked McNally but as you say things started going wrong and we pushed him out and gave it to Smith.
I can't remember the 3 games but Smith turned out to be the worst coach we've ever had. Certainly the performance on the field implied that.
A poor run does not mean we should just hop across to anyone else just because we don't like Agar.
My points about jumping on the bandwagon I may be able to explain like this.
When you do maths at school, you won't get top marks by just giving an answer even if sometimes right.
You have to show your workings.
Workings for these threads are not logical in my mind.
Every coach we've ever had has been beaten by the top sides at some stage. Heavily too.
It's topical to say Agar has been rubbish forever but he hasn't. We've had good form under him.
Those that want Agar out would say our top 8 finish was down to players not Agar. Ellis in particular.
But when form goes it is him.
I'm not that impressed with Washbrook but some are now saying his tackle count is only high because he is 3rd man in. Apart from the fact it plainly isn't true, we could do with a few more 3rd men in the tackle.
It goes on for many examples but although Agar may be passed his sell by now, partly because the fans won't accept him, I haven't seen a good enough reason to swing the axe.....apart from bad results, and there are multiple reasons for that at the moment.
I have to agree with Tryscorer that he has been clear of his feelings from the start.
If it turns out Agar has to go then so be it but I hope MC and KH get a good replacement rather than just taking what's available.