I certainly think he's played a lot better this year than last.

Horo is quality, his reading of the game is first class resulting in his decision making in defense been probably the best in the squad. He can play second row, 13 or . Plus he is a leader on the pitch,

I think the issue we have is that Horo is taking up a quota spot that could, arguably, be used to much greater effect.

Hypothetically, i would rather let Horo go, bring in Hadley who is a very similar player and free up a quota spot...given the figures stack up of course.

Atkins would make a good replacement to the second row

Hadley over Horo any time for me. Both based on their Wakey form obviously.

Hadley hasn't been that good at Hull. with Horo you know what your getting

Nail on the head there, Hadley can't even get in the Hull side on a regular basis, Horo has been as good as any of our back rowers this season, why let him go for some unknown quantity from Aus.

And we don't know what we are getting with Hadley

Hadley was brilliant for us in his loan spell and the club wanted to keep him, id imagine we would jump at the chance of bringing him back. Also, i was not suggesting Horo has been poor.

In terms of a quota spot replacement for Horo, if he leaves, we might be looking at a known quantity already in SL. Id also argue Big Dave, Arona and Tupou were 'unknown' quantities to most of us on here and look how they turned out...

Thought Horo was due to retire at the end of this year. Think he's done reasonably well for us and is adaptable but maybe the club think we can get a bitmore from a quota spot. We can't just retain the same squad moving forward or we'll just standstill or more likely go backwards.

Would happily see Hadley return, don't think he's had a fair crack at Hull looking in from the outside but can't have been terrible last season as he made the Knights tour to PNG.

Shame for him as he seems to have stepped up and shown his worth since the injury 'crisis', but until then was nothing out the ordinary. Unless that was more to do with playing for a contract

When fit, Hadley has played, had a few injuries though, but can't remember many if any games he has been not picked in the 17.

I'd keep him at Hull for the right price whilst at Hull I've never seen him after other than solid so if can get a better deal then good luck to him.

I can't believe he wouldn't choose Wakey over Rovers when you look at the two clubs, unless he doesn't want to travel.

Didn't Andrew say he wanted to play at the same club as David...

Was just going on some posts I'd read and the sending out on loan due to salary cap issues. He was a really good fit for us in 2017 and pretty certain he would be again. HKR can possibly offer him a bit more than we can money wise to be honest.

Nick Scruton also chose the money (don't blame him fwiw), and look how that turned out.