from the few games I saw of him this year he looks to have a decent kicking game and linked up well with the forwards. Just thought he'd make a decent alternative to what we already have.

If he was British maybe, but he's a Quota spot, so not for me. That place will be used by a Propr imo.

We are looking at a prop to fill our last overseas spot so Drinkwater isn’t a goer. I believe we are looking over here for extra halfback cover though, or for a hooker with both Wood and Randall able to cover the halves.

Didn't see him do much for Leigh but hen again who could with a starting front row of Hock, Higham, and Tickle.

Lets hope that if we are looking at an overseas prop, they make more of an impact than our last one we had.

Good point Willzay, but sometimes, players do play better around a better calibre of players, and yes he would struggle beghind that pack. How many times over the years have we defended our halves because they played behind a beaten pack.

Allgood played reasonably well for us he was just unfortunate with injuries

He wasn't bad for us when he was on the pitch, it was getting him on the pitch that was the problem. Yes, he was unlucky, but it seemed that every injury problem he picked up always appeared to take longer than expected to shake off. Unfortunately for him, he had the same issues at Hull KR.

It became all too reminiscent of a certain other prop we had 2-3 seasons ago that came from Leeds

You make a good point regarding props especially overseas props.

Overseas signing to ourselves and SL in general and even before SL have always been a mixed bag. However where props are concerned we've really been unlucky. It's especially annoying as Wakefield have always been willing to push out the boat where props are concerned and have signed some big names for little return.

For me the best ones have been Watene, Korky, Fifita, Fritz and Shelford - there may be a few more but you get the drift. By this I mean they offered VFM and lived up to or even exceeded expectations - that doesn't mean they were world beaters.

Those who were either disappointing, short lived, no better than British players or just plain garbage were as follows and there are some big names in there. They weren't necessarily bad but just didn't give real value or meet expectations.

Poore, Tronc, Graham, Todd, Allgood, Hood, Stoic, O'Brien, Keating, Masella, Lima, Leaeno, Paea, Anderson (opinions differ) and the abomination that was Hickey.

Doesn't make great reading does it. There are some big names in that list and some hefty wages. We seem to have done pretty well in most other positions where overseas players are concerned but to me Prop remains a but of a poison chalice.

So I'll reserve judgement on any Aussie FR we sign and pray for the best

Stosic was a fantastic prop forward I thought, one of the best. Take his contribution over a Korky every single day of the week.

Well I didn't rate him that highly, but if you read my post again one of the criteria was 'short lived'. For whatever reason he was. I'd say that was a fair description 1 season 18 games - you have to question whether its worth bringing a player half way around the world for that. He wasn't a failure but he wasn't a success imho.

I also agree about Korki, never a favourite of mine but you have to say he gave us some good service 144 games over roughly five year. He was imo opinion a relatively successful signing.

I accept opinions regarding my list will differ but overall I think it's fair and makes the point.

Shelford, yes. He was great.

Every time this come up, I feel compelled to declare myself as the sole member of the Shane Tronc fan club; he was a genuinely classy front rower, and his stats were outrageously good for the short time he was with us - he continued to be top metre maker for some months after leaving.

I heard that he left after the club didn't honour some promises that were made to him - but that could be hearsay; either way, I'm certain that if he'd stayed with us, we'd be talking about him as one of our best ever imports. As it stands, it's probably fair to include him on your list, because for whatever reason, we didn't see anywhere near enough of him.