Tom Johnston for me.

Ton Johnstone - no disrespect to Liam but no contest.

Correct. Liam was a quick player with a certain versatility. Tom Johnstone is pure class and although he will have his bad days will IMHO go on to be a super star paleyer.

Johnstone over Kay definately. But i also think Kay could have been doing every bit as well as BJB if not better and for an awful lot less coin. He'd have no problem switching wings.

Although Liam did score 4 tries against our nearest and dearest which will be remembered for a few years yet, he didn't play too much for us so no contest, Johnstone everyday.

Johnstone over Kay, but Kay over BJB any day of the week.

Thats why kay is playing in the championship! and Bjb is playing in super league

Tom every day of the week

If Liam Kay was good he would be playing in super league .BJB is one of reasons we are not in the bottom four about time people gave him a break

Exactly!

The hit on Handley that freed the ball, allowing Hall to score the winner at Leeds

That chase back and tackle on Sau that prevented Salford edging in front with minutes to go and allowed Lynne to score the match clincher.

The final try against WRrington to kill their comeback.

Give the lad a break, he's shown for a number of seasons that he has class and that's permanent as they say, but form. . . .

Its not even like the guy is in bad form! Just doesn't score as many as Johnstone so doesn't appear as flashy

Had Ali Lautiti been injured that day this thread wouldn't exist.

You want plenty of custard with that humble pie :

Spot on chissitt most forget it was Ali that set him up that day and most wingers would have scored those