By that logic you could put Crowther, Ashurst or Kirmond there too.....And Ali...and possibly Annakin
I like Sio where he is.

Yeah, because I only based my judgement on the fact he's a back rower and nothing more!

!

As I said, I didn't form my opinion based purely on the fact that he's a back rower.

ie I used some of his personal attributes and abilities as an individual player as well.

It's not that hard to spot in a 3 line post!

Think the pack seems to have possibly sorted out its best combinations with Anderson coming back being in that best 17 along with Lauitiiti, Simon and Godinet (probably) on the bench.

Locke nailed on at full back (if fit) with that X factor ability.

Johnstone has pure talent and has to be on the wing with Tansey in my opinion on the other (dependent on form).

Centres must be Arundel and Lynne unless Lee Smith is signed and plays the next couple of games?
Half backs Miller and Tim Smith.

Has Miller's four try feat clouded the picture. Great individual tries of the type scored by a stand off or hooker but nothing in his game suggests he has the first idea about organising a team from scrum half. And we still do not have a kicking game worthy of the name.

FB:Locke
W:Tansy
C: Lee smith (hopefully we sign him)
C: Lyne
W:Hall
SO:Miller
SH:Smith
P:Anderson
H:Mc Shane
P:Son
SR:Ashurt
SR:Kirke
LF:Sio

Bench
Simon
Ali
Dan smith
Pita (hopefully will be fit for the Middle 8's)

Kirke? You are taking the mickey!

Think his experience will be vital come them middle 8's
Matty Ryan for me has been very poor this season, granted kirke not been great but just for his experience alone put his in front of Ryan for me.

Hall on the wing AND Kirke in the second row!?!? You do like your players lacking in heart and commitment don't you?

Not at all, it's called a forum int it, people have different opinions. I think hall could make a very good winger gives us another option on the last play kick with him been tall which we have not had for a long time. Would of said Young Johnston but as seen at hull and cas game, we saw the best and worst of him and with the Middle 8's coming up unfortunately for me I don't think we can afford to risk him.
Plus I wouldn't play Riley as shown from yesterday don't have that killer instinct.
I would of had Owen there but obviously we can't, so for me hall would be the next best option

Take Dan Smith out, he's off to Huddersfield. You have got Anthony Mullally on loan for the rest of the season though before he joins Leeds.