We can speculate all day but ultimately we need to use what evidence we do have to make an assessment. I appreciate it is early in the season but his performances in preseason and on Sunday have not been up to standard. Most worrying for me it looks to be his energy levels and enthusiasm which is low.

Interesting that he is playing in the reserves, you could probably take a few things from that.

At the end of the day though against Fev in what was lacklustre performance from the entire team it was the younger lads who came on towards the end of the game and and made an impact when the more seasoned pro's couldn't so it is probably only right and fair, that if a player isn't contributing to the levels expected of them that they step up and get a chance.

I think it is a positive sign that the club is moving in the right direction when we can drop someone who would be classed as a key player and replace him with another experienced player.

The Catalans trip is a bit of a hiding to nothing. If we pick up a win it will be an unexpected bonus even with their absentees and regardless it shows the wider squad nobody is guaranteed a shirt.

Hopefully KT can use the next couple of weeks to get back to basics and rediscover his mojo. He is a quality player when he is on and I think we are going to need him near his best as it is in my opinion going to be a tough season.

Lineham for a start

Did he? Debatable.

The only impact i saw him have on the game was letting the firstctry in.

A little chap, with white legs, Griffiths I think his name was.

Lineham might not have had the best of games, but does that warrant being dropped really.
Also you said Lineham for a start so does that mean there are others also that deserved dropping?.

Scrappy game difficult to referee I thought he blew for what he saw, think both sides got the odd bit of good fortune, but being biased I thought the 2 linesmen had poor games which didn't help the ref.

If Kershaw is fit I’d have him start vs Catalans at the expense of Lineham definitely.

Been very unimpressed with Lineham so far.

The defensive effort for the Gale try was appalling and totally unacceptable.

If anyone was going to the reserves game tonight it has been cancelled FYI.

Your rubbishing some ones opinion

I’m pointing out that either of you could be right

There is no definitive here

The only evidence we have is that Willie says he's dropped. I'm prepared to believe that.
Saying I'm blinded by passion is a bit strange considering no one knows Kelepi's vax status.
I'm saying it doesn't matter to me either way. He's still dropped. But it seems it does matter to you to prove something you can't prove.
So I asked why it matters to you? Why not just believe what Willie says? It's not like you are whistleblowing some great conspiracy.

Rubbishing someone’s opinion states the poster who does it all the time. Your hypocrisy is quite breathtaking at times.

So he’s the only player to ever do that? Players make mistakes and wingers mistakes tend to be more obvious than most. It was a pee poor effort but that tends to be the reasons most tries get scored.

Most games would be nil nil draws were it not for defensive errors, very few tries are what you’d call pure.

One of our tries came from a glaring error from Hull, will they drop said player. You’re being hyper critical imo and if your lad progresses you’ll find that’s not always a good thing.

I have also been unimpressed with Lineham so far Also think we need more than what J Crowther offers at loseforward by all means keep him in the squad but think you got to offer more than just tackling for such a crucial roll

Is Kershaw still a Trinity player ?

I believe he is.