Yeah, not sure, granted we were looking from the Northstand but Catalans looked to have plenty of cover out there ready to bundle Kershaw into touch. Was anyone in that corner who could confirm or deny this ??

Gale would be a vast improvement on Lino. Even if he missed half a season at least we wouldn’t have to watch the headless chicken. Then maybe Walker would get a go and in all honesty Walker is not great.

Gale’s already 34. We should be looking elsewhere, he’s done.

I know Lino isnt liked by many, but to me Miller is an even bigger problem. The bloke is thick, should never be the captain and cant read a game. I was bored watching his high kicks to Tom Davies it was obvious a failed tactic but he did not adapt

Kershaw would probably have had too far to run to get past cover defenders. What was needed was a little kick on the inside where we had players in support who would probably have dotted down - seemed to attempt this but made his mind up a little too late. Ref was as inconsistent as I've seen and seemed to ref both sides differently regarding ruck and set restarts etc. Overall, effort plenty effort but poor execution and game smarts like most games. That Catalan side were not any good really. I reckon they'd have been beat by most teams.

There was one out there today, that was linked with us a couple of years back and rang rings round ours. Sadly he wasn't rated at the time

Can’t agree. In that he may be a bit dim at times but come on PB he’s MENSA compared to Lino. I’m not convinced that this is the real Lino, it’s his twin as I’m sure this one would never get a game in the NRL

Who?

Drinkwater, streets ahead of the headless chickens we have in the halves

I asked you a straight question Vasty. Don't decend into the 'you are blinded' camp that can't explain their point.
For me, switching the centres round has worked. It's not like Murphy was getting any great passes recently.
Most agree Gaskell has played better since the change.

I agree, Poaching is liable but that includes tge good stuff too. They put a move on today that put Ashurst through a gap. Clearly a planned move as Miller hasn't been able to do that in ages but has done it twice recently.

I don't think Hall or Murphy's performance has suffered since the change either.

For me. Putting Tanginoa in SR is a mistake. But as nearly the whole forum moan when he isn't you can hardly blame him for giving him a chance.

We tried to get him and his price was more than most could afford. Which is why he's at Catalan.

But I agree. Head and shoulders better.

We've not had a decent half back since Finny got too old.
Hence why we've been on a decline since. Tried to paper over the cracks by signing Brough which failed.

Whatever you're opinions on Miller or Lino the basic facts are not one can control a game and neither of them have a kicking game in open play.

I am sorry and I know some of you will not agree but I believe we who support the club deserve better. If we survive which is still open to debate then we cannot go through another season like the last three.
We have seen players leave and not replaced thereby weakening the squad and it’s ability to compete. We have kept our end of the bargain by buying season tickets, merchandise and all the other additional costs we incur. We should expect the club to do their bit and generate enough income to improve the team year on year. If we survive then next season will be our 25th in SL I believe and what legacy do we have in that time.
I admit I have little confidence things will improve but they should for supporters who still believe in the club.

We say effort i just seen the 3rd try back and where clearly langi was out of play but there was absolutely no urgency from kershaw to get to the kick in the first place,