Doncaster

I've liked all the signings we've made so far, they all look like they'll make us a stronger team but this one would be a bit disapointing and pointess tbh. Looks no better than Harry for me. Doesn't have a kicking game, runs across the pitch aimlessly and imo just doesn't look SL quality. I'd also imagine he'd be after a decent contract.

If he comes I hope I'm made to look stupid.

No thank you. Shannon McDonnell please.

If it's a choice between McDonnell and Miller, it would be McDonnell every time, very good FB, just got injured at the wrong time for Hull and Shaul doing really well meant it was pointless keeping a very highly paid player not in the 17. I would do a really good medical on him though.

Shifty Cats description of Miller is spot on IMO.

I will believe it only when it is official because I struggle to understand what he could add to the team. I guess it boils down to Sammut or Miller therefore if you owned a Super
League club which would you want to sign ?

I'd sign a hooker and play Godinet at 6

I agree, played well of Smith. As other have said would much rather have a centre/full-back. I'd back the lad if he does come and not write him off until he has a good chance.

If it's true, Sammut at full back, Hall to centre and Lyne out to the wing. A massive pack and plenty of skill from 1-7. Quite exciting if you ask me.

Sammutt at Full Back is a non-starter for me. Look how easily he got swatted off by Carney in the Cas game at home. It was like Carney was being irritated by a fly and he didn't need to break stride to score. Sammutt may be dangerous when returning kicks or joining the line but defensively he is lightweight. I would rather see. Max Jowitt at fullback but the best option is Hall with Jowitt coming in for selected games.

Lets be fair the Gerry Round, the best full back ever to wear the Trinity shirt would have all on to stop Carney when he is in full flight.
Sammut is a quality RL player I hope we are planning on playing him at 6 as he and Smith seem to me to have styles of play that will complement each other. I am not convinced that Pita is a 6, I think he is style of play, his strengths, make him well suited to playing the modern style hooker role.

I agree that Pita is a great hooker. The problem to me is that we then have one of our best players on the bench for half the game.
I like him at half back with Smith as they compliment each other too especially in defence.

Gerry Round would have taken Carney round the legs unlike today when people try to tackle his flabby gut.

Craig Halls defensive qualities are no better than Sammuts at fullback, unless you know something we dont?

Don't think we should sign Miller...nothing against the guy, but IMO he has always underwhelmed at Hull, hence the reason he went on dual reg to Donny. As others have said, we need another centre or full back please.

Sammut playing alongside Smith. Godinet hooker rotating with Mcshane. Sammut in halfs with Smith looked very good. warrington away??? Best win of season