To be fair Vastman, Tommy's defence is not the best and he's done OK for us.

Think you've missed the point a bit.

What I'm saying is that you rarely see defensive highlights on these videos, so we don't know if he can defend, I have no idea myself, he could be brilliant.

Also don't agree about TJ, sorry but I think his defence is fine, it's a bit of a myth built up IMHO, tall poppy syndrome. His defence is not what sets him apart obviously but it's always been fit for purpose.

He can defend very good squad player and knows were the try line is

Excellent, thanks for the info.

Don't suppose you know if we've actually signed him? I know he's a Leigh player now but you might know the gossip.

Excellent, thanks for the info.

Don't suppose you know if we've actually signed him? I know he's a Leigh player now but you might know the gossip.

Good luck to the lad and lets hope that he turns out to be the next Reece Lyne, another great signing from Hull.

Looks like he's agreed to sign for york according to Hull Live.
Shame that.

So, who do you believe about what - nobody until the club announce it!

We just have to wait and see and hope he has a change of heart.

Quote: cheshirecat57 "Looks like he's agreed to sign for york according to Hull Live. Shame that.'" Link here... https://www.hulldailymail.co.uk/sport/r ... ll-6200167

Quote: cheshirecat57 "Looks like he's agreed to sign for york according to Hull Live. Shame that.'" Link here... https://www.hulldailymail.co.uk/sport/r ... ll-6200167

If we're looking at home grown centres currently in the Championship, we could do a lot worse than Thomas Minns in my opinion. Contracted to fev so that will probably be a sticking point.

He's signed up with Newcastle

He's selling himself very short then. Fair play to Newcastle. Very much a punching above their weight signing that

Minns has had some bad injuries over the years though, and he didn't play for three years following his drugs ban and then breaking his foot twice, and he's also had other personal issues that have been well documented.

He was going ok for Fev, though nota guaranteed starter, when he broke his leg in July.

I don't think he's selling himself at all short going to Newcastle, who are now full time, and it wouldn't surprise me if Fev had decided against offering him a new contract anyway, or at least not one to compare with what Newcastle might have offered, given his injuries. He's a similar story to Brad Day who has also gone to Newcastlle after being plagued by injuries over the last couple of years.

Also worth remembering re the comments about Newcastle "punching above their weight" that they have the finances to go full-time and have made some eyecatching signings, such as Akuma Ta'ai this year and then Alex Foster from Cas for next year