To be fair to Washbrook he's missed 3 games in 3 years. Some of our 'bigger' names have spent more time on the sidelines than on the playing field.

Spot on, I really don't know what some people want from a player - I concede he's no world beater but he is as they say generally fit for purpose.

He had a poor start to this season, but has improved as the weeks went on; anyone expecting him to bust the line and create magic is wrongheaded - he's never done that and he never will, but as a resilient tackle machine who generally won't let you down, he does the job.

1 more year - seems fair enough to me.

I'm relatively happy with this, the last thing I want to see is this team being dismantled and having another pre season re build, I'd rather we have a bit of continuity.

I don't mind reduced in numbers but would hope the squad is of better quality.

I knew he hasn't missed many games while he's been with us but that's some record for a forward.

Happy with a year.

Not a massive fan, but he adds some stability.
Should play second row though this year, as he adds little in attack.
He's no better than Duncan Magilvery was and nobody ever thought to put him at 13.

I thought MacGilivray was great. Tackling technique was perfect. But was you say, not a LF.