Think the only thing that let Fox down was his jumping boots!Apart from that I thought he put a lot of hard work in!

One more win than last year with 5 to go as well. Done ok this year hopefully even better to come.

Agree and it's no great shame losing out to Ryan Hall, the blokes class and quite a bit taller than Foxy.

I think Collis has done well, John has the skills but didn't manage to get it going with Timmy before he was dropped - still think this lad has got a future at the club though.

I'll give you Mellars and Southern, although I think Southern's problems couldn't have been foreseen tbh.

Collis is quallity and will only get better, he is not 100% fit.


Agar does deserve credit for whats been acheived so far.

agree 100% ref Collis and to be fair to Mellers for my money hes a winger the jury is out on Southern I think we could all eat out words next season John also looked very good on Saturday

Collis hasn't been fully fit since the early part of the season - even busted, it's clear he's a quality player; I reckon he'll shine for us next season.

We've been unlucky with the Southern situation and he's been mis-used - again, I think he'll go well next year, if he's still with us.

The jury is out on Mellars - I don't think he's done what he seemed to be capable of at Crusaders, but I'll grant that he's been played out of position; personally, I wouldn't dislodge Fox or Cockayne in favour of him, so a bit of a quandary.

I'm not sure what the future holds for Isaac John - he showed a lot of potential, but with a settled pairing of Sykes and Smith, he'd spend next season doing pretty much what he's done for the last couple of months.

good coach bad coach hard to judge really.

Here's my theory , the up turn in form and our forwards suddenly looking stronger and fitter could be linked to the inclusion of Ellis in the side. We look far more organised around PTB and the way we are moving forward.

Bit of a stretch and not sure I'd put it down to that, he only played 20 minutes or so last week and didn't look great, looked fitter this week mind and distributed the ball very well.

He played a good half hour last week against a very strong wind, thought he went ok, last night i thought he was very good but even better was agars timing on the introduction of Wood, he got that one spot on

He could do with a hat.

Peeked variety to stop the sun going in his eyes.

James webster needs one too

I cant believe that you think his performance was anything other than poor. Yep he did run the ball in hard and looked for work but his errors in defense were utterly terrible. Your view is akin to reviewing a resteraunt by saying the starter and main were fine although i was a little disappointed to find a turd in my triffle.

I don't know what Fox was playing at trying to defend that 1st Hall try? Sinfield put across a poor kick that Hall took above his head but Fox appeared to run past him and slip, leaving a clear run to the line. Hall almost repeated the act later in the game, with Fox over running and slipping again, but lost control of the ball.

Credit to Wood, he did have a good spell when he came on. I remember Brent Todd once breaking a tackle though!

Collis was our weakest link but the try just gave him some save face. He even got pushed into touch by Rob Burrow at one point.

Think it's quite obvious Collis is not fully fit, the man has class written all over him. Needs a good off season and come back fully fit.

Thought Ellis went really well his distribution is excellent.

As for the wingers, the position is becoming more and more crucial as they get somewhat isolated, BOTH our wingers are prone to make the wrong decisions on the other hand both are pretty high in the meters gained chart.

Take a big positive out of all this, one interception and three tries from kicks, our defence was'nt too bad was it!!!!

At the start of the season I said Agar should be given a fair chance and he's doing fine. Keep up the good work Shergar.