The effort he put in at the crusaders game when he knew we were super league was shameful and really hurt, offered nothing attack or defence, even wildie was shouting at him at one point. Either he had 2 broken legs and 2 broken arms or he's just a plain bad player

Ooooh this is interesting?!?!? and completely ignored because most people won't know who Scott Porter is.

Scotty is a very competent scrum half who can kick goals and has a very good open kicking game... however he has barely played this year at all... and I can find no current trace of him playing even at NSW level... I think he played 1 game for the sharks first grade this year and is out of contract for next season.

Would be a risky... but potentially brilliant ... signing

give the kid a chance hes played out of position all bloody season

Thought you'd gone Underground for good Andrew

if we are to move on, We need players who can tackle, Tommy lee has missed quite a few, Maybe not all is fault, maybe more the lack of knowledge of how to defend (not just Tommy lee either) the team too ? he might be ok with a stronger team around him? but if wildie is to play? we cant be carrying too many? if u know what i mean !

Ps i did think he did ok for us the 1st half of the season too...

Lee has not provided the leadership he should have done and his defence has been really bad for a while. He is not a halfback and should be behind Ellis and Wildie next year at 9.

No, he should be behind Ellis and Davey next year.

Wildie should be being given an opportunity at half back which is where his future lies IMO

Totally agree but does this out of position business make him arms and legs stop working, the last 10 games or so he's been involved has baffled me, surely kear has been having a laugh selecting him

Scott Murrell linked with us.

Yes I have heard scott murrell to either wakey or salford.

Do you really buy into some second rate Aussie coming in for Young British Players ? This is where we fall down and why we will always be behind the Aussies.
If we are going to bring them over bring a superstar and let the kids learn from them.
as a prime example take Hickey - do you seriously believe we dont have kids in the UK playing prop who are better than this bloke ? he does not even have respect for the game in this country or he would not have turned up in the state he did (and still is by all accounts) No thanks let them keep the NSW cup brigade !!

It is possible to bring over decent players who aren't big names at the time.

Oh - and don't use Hickey as the example, we know!

Use delaney instead

who does scott porter play for is he any good