Fair enough for me,we had the faith to sign him in first place so lets give him a decent chance to prove himself when fit.Still happy with signings generally,cant be champagne all the time.

I agree. But I'd like a young English make weight.
I am also being hypocritical because I'd keep Hendo, but I think he offers more and isn't blocking a route through in the same way Tony is.

Motu Tony isnt too bad and has played fairly well in the few minutes we saw him. Jeremy Smith however is pants.... He is slow, passes the ball at 2mph and is predictable. I would ship him off as quickly as possible

Poor do for me. No reason to keep him in my opinion. First signing that is a genuine dissapointment for me.

good bloke, good player , can play in almost any position and has a wealth of experience . don't see any problem with this myself.

My concern is who is likely to get in the match day squad given all things being equal formwise. Tony or Annakin?

I think this is an ok signing dont forget boys he can play fullback,winger,hooker,looseforward and to an extent . So hes a good squad player to have around when the inevitable injury crisis hits!

This is a sensible signing for the club.

Blaymire is rumoured to be leaving, Vievers is OOC, and there is no evidence to suggest Tongia will get a new deal as we haven't seen him play for us yet. At Hull Motu made the full back position his own, and leaves us with our first specialist full back for 2012, and before people mention Murphy the lad is a specialist centre who wants to play centre! Tony will have been signed as an out and out full back.

1. Tony
2. George
3. Murphy
4. Mellars
5. Tongia

That obviously assuming George and Tongia stay. However, I can't see George playing second fiddle and playing out on the wing so swap him and Mellars around?

Tony will probably end up playing at 13 anyway!