Would rather go with what we already have in that position.

Really need to focus on replacing Hall, Scruton and Anderson also adding the 3rd half back

Is this post a wind up ?
Ashurst I can agree with.
Crowther ? Maybe in a few years.
Molloy ? Not as good and is just as injury prone.
Sio ? I like him but not the same type of player
A.Tupou ? Has been, shown nothing to suggest he's as good as Mariano as things stand now.
Arona ? Needs to show more. A fit Mariano over him anyday.
Batchelor is rated by better RL heads than me so I'd leave that one open to debate.

Agar hated Mariano and played him in the reserves as much as he could. A player treated badly by a bad coach. Bring him back.

A fit Mariano you mention, isn't that most people's argument, that he hasn't been fit for two seasons, I wouldn't touch him with a barge pole.

He's a good player but way too injury prone. Don't think his body is up to the rigours of week in week out superleague.

Reservers how long are you going back.? Injury prone now wont play SL again i dont recon.

Frankie has been fantastic for us when he's actually been on the field. Sorry to see him go but even when fully fit he now has a lot of 2nd rowers ahead of him. On the injury situation none of them have been re-occurring, they have all been different. We took Jake Webster from HKR a few years ago after he had been out injured for them on a regular basis but once again they were not re-occuring and he's been great for us both on and off the field.

Defence???? one man, are you kidding, probably has the same defensive qualities has all the rest of the Wakey Trinity players over the last 5 seasons. look at the tables for Super League points diff. over the years,Wakey are always down at the botton of the pile. thats always been one of our biggest problems. he's one player, the team as a whole have always been sh i te in defence.

No thanks, too injury prone and I don't think he's good enough at this stage.

Heart as big as a pea.

Kirmond is just as injury prone these days, he always seems to be trying to get fit, then he's down with something else. I'd put Kirmond in the same bracket as Mariano but at least Mariano can run through a gap every now and then.

And how do you compare the two defensively??...

Come on the heart the size of a pea baloney is wearing thin now. He's a pro SL player for gods sake. He played in a team that was haemorrhaging points just like Kirmond does now. I've never heard any Cas fans saying his defence stinks.