I am not going to apologise for being passionate about the club I support & as for the OP I may well have been shouting at JD, but I certainly wasn't swearing as you mistakenly allege.

Fine, I wasn't shouting at JD when he was 2 feet away - he was able to hear me well enough.

I'm glad that JD wanted to respond, but that doesn't change the fact that all we have from this year's cup campaign is the dross that we saw on Saturday.

I'll be the first to admit that I may not have been as vocal if it had been a league match where we always have another day, but the Quins side on Saturday was no better than the one we played at the end of January and we should have beaten them easily despite the players that were missing/left/serving a drugs ban.

IMO (and at the end of the day we're all entitled to have one) JD was anonymous on Saturday & his match-costing error cannot go unchallenged. Whilst JD has been one of the best players at the club during his time with us, I don't think he can ever be described as a "great" player and has certainly not been providing "great" performances since the end of 2006.

The time for rose-tinted glasses is over. The harsh reality is that we're fighting to justify our place in SL beyond next season and that needs strong leadership from JK as head coach & also from our captain. I've said on many other occasions before this weekend that I don't feel that JD is the right person to be captain on the pitch & that if we had a fully fit squad he would struggle to be in what I would consider to be our best 17. I'm sure none of you will be surprised that I still hold that opinion, but neither is it any stronger an opinion that before Saturday's match.

I know that many of our fans belive that JD can do no wrong, and I'll leave all of you to have those rose-tinted views.

He's dross the teams dross and the coach picks the wrong Captain

and to top it all the fans that don't agree are "rose tinted".

to be fair al a whole thred to have a go at a fan who had already admitted it was him is a bit sad.

dont know the guy but some of the self righteous garbage on here is beyond belief!

Don't disagree with that.

Nope i don't either and i think he's stood his corner and aired his views very well, don't mean i can't take the mick out of his post though does it

no mate so long as i can get drunk and hurl abuse at you without you knowing its me!

Anytimes fine by me.

thats the spirit!

Quote Doratheexplorer="Doratheexplorer"Lots of errors this year. can not deny commitment but: superleague.co.uk/statistics_pla ... eason=2010'" wheres the link to players who stayed on the ship when it was sinking and refused contracts from other clubs? maybe you have one on how many games a player has put his hand up after recovering from what appeared to be carer threatening injuries. JD as dropped a couple of balls and gets tied quicker but hes the best man in the entire camp to take on the mantle of captain and to me he will always be a modern day hero...in fact IMHO hes my number 1 player in the SL eara

Quote Doratheexplorer="Doratheexplorer"Lots of errors this year. can not deny commitment but: superleague.co.uk/statistics_pla ... eason=2010'" wheres the link to players who stayed on the ship when it was sinking and refused contracts from other clubs? maybe you have one on how many games a player has put his hand up after recovering from what appeared to be carer threatening injuries. JD as dropped a couple of balls and gets tied quicker but hes the best man in the entire camp to take on the mantle of captain and to me he will always be a modern day hero...in fact IMHO hes my number 1 player in the SL eara

That's exactly the point of these forums. We're all entitled to have our opinions & at times others will disagree, take the or both.

I don't expect everyone to agree with my views all the time, but I'm happy to defend my points of view to the hilt.

I could have turned & walked away before JD got to me (which would have made me look even more stupid than some of you already think) or I could have continued having a go after he said "I made a mistake, sorry" but what value would there have been in that.

I have never called JD's integrity as a human being into question as he is one of the truest gents you could ever meet.

I don't think think you are stupid and would you really care if i did.

Mountains and mole hills spring to mind, hell i've said things at games i wish i had not, its called passion/frustration.

Lets move on.

What's wrong with wearing older shirts to games? Some of our recent ones have been shocking…just because you don't want to spend near on £100 a year to wear something you don't like does not make you any less of a 'true' supporter.

totally agree , i refuse to throw away a 40 quid shirt after 7 months , my fave is the one i got 4 years ago with daddy and 1 on the back as a gift from my lads on fathers day. also i think many of us just love the white with traditional red n blue bands.