Lomax slipped into Lautiti who didn't make contact with the head. Shouldn't have been a penalty and won't result in a ban. Amor isn't a dirty player but even the nicest of guys e.g. Collis can throw a dirty tackle once in a while. Amor was obviously frustrated with how that particularly play was unfolding and threw the arm with intent. He'll cope a ban without question but I'm sure his previous good record will be taken into account

If he got put on report for the tackle on Lomax, I think if he had gone any lower, he would have broken his fingers on the ground.

In Ali's case, he was committed to the tackle and Lomax slipped, had he not slipped he would of made contact to the midriff, I would agree that I've never seen that kind of side to Amor and I commented to the guys next to me at the time "Where did that come from" it was definitely intentional and he should have walked however totally out of character for a player who I believe as one of the best to wear a trinity shirt in recent years

Wasn't too annoyed with the Ali penalty. His arm did connect with Lomax's head, albeit accidentally, but my understanding is that the ref's are told to penalise in that situation, as the obligation is on the tackler to avoid the head regardless of how it comes about. Amor, however, might have a couple of weekends off.

We don't need a report system as all games are reviewed on video anyway. It just gives the ref a chance to avoid making a tough decision

Lautiti one was a penalty but Lomax was nearly on the floor when he hit him. Penalty on more.

Amor was out if character, but is was a deliberate attack to the head. I think he got frustrated from being taken advantage of at the penalty and tried to play the big man. He deserves a ban, probably 2 game, he also should of walked.

To me it was a calculated deliberate attack born of frustration.

No it doesn't sound like Amor. However he didn't used to try and con pens and whinge and whine every tackle either for us. Obviously being around Wellens has had an effect already.

From my view Matt Ryan took a quick tap and ran at Amor who was offside and right infront of him and since Amor did not move out the way Ryan ran over her. Amor gets back up and is probably embarresed and goes abit OTT in the tackle and makes contact on the head a player who is 6ft 6. Deliberate yes, is Amor a dirty player? No.

Exactly what happened; I was yards away and watched the whole thing unfold.

I must have been next to you both. That's what I saw too.

I've noticed this with a few club that give away penalties when they know they have the score line in there favour, these professional fouls should be picked up on and remove the said player for ten.

today there two head highs neither worth the red but one a yellow, Ali's was accidently where Amor did take his swing to the extreme

Out of the 3 challenges in question I think the only one that was intentional and deserving of a ban was the Wilkin one.

You are wrong. Amor was a bad one.

It's just an opinion, I think it's too early to say if either of us are right or wrong as such. Obviously I've only seen it once, as have you I imagine. My initial reaction is that it wasn't as bad as the Wakefield fans made out, or Wigan fans for that matter.

From what i've seen of Amor previously i'd agree with you 100%. On the Lomax issue i'm sure i can remember a similar situation with him last season where he slipped and got caught head high when he wouldn't have done if he'd stayed upright. I think there was quite a bit of debate about it at the time as it did result in him leaving the field.