Not really. As has been shown on here some prefer the last game to be the deciding fixture. If other sports tried that formula I'd expect done of those sports supporters to like to as well. Licensing was great too, just managed poorly by the RFL. lots more progress with great young players coming through and better facilities being built. This is exactly what was needed. Licensing should have carried on for 20 years at least to keep seeing the benefit. The RFL needed to have the balls to take licences off clubs, but it didn't.

I think a lot of clubs should have had the balls to embrace the spirit of licensing too, and use it as an opportunity to shape up. Sadly, they didn't, and we are one of them. Money thrown down the drain.

As for the new structure, it's a tough call. We've experimented with so many different formats in the past, it's hard to know where fairness lies. I'm happy enough with the playoffs, although for the sake of what I see as fairness, I'd probably reduce it to a straight knock-out between the top 4.

Stay with 14 - we need the 13 home fixtures and bring back P&R (1 up - 1 down) with minimum standards.

Bring back the Yorkshire and Lancashire Cups plus it'd be great if teams like Australia and New Zealand toured and played the top 8 clubs again.

Keep the system for Grand Final but promotion and relegation is needed.

should be 14 SL and 18 Championship 2 up 2 down whoever is bottom two top two
Play home and away 26 games SL 34 championship
scrap magic
Champions team who finish 1st after 26 games end of
Bring back the Premiership final
bring back winter RL and along with that international tours because the seasons dont clash
Bring back the end of season CC final in May
Bring back the County Cups as a pre season warm up

Bring back winter rugby? Really? How many games do you want in a season with league , premiership, county cup pre season, challenge cup. Too much for the players. Unless you get knocked out first round of everything !

Have to say I love the magic weekend. Been to every one. Love a play off series but would only have a top 5. Enjoy the challenge cup final being in August. Only thing is change is a mid season break for internationals

Got to say i would stick with licensing but has been pointed out, the RFL have made a mockery of the concept and smaller clubs like Wake have not used it to their benefit.
If we go back to P+R we will have more over the hill imports coming over to prop up the promoted clubs for a season at the expense of developing our own.
The gap between Aus and England will become even greater.

I'd suggest its the gap between Italy and England that is our biggest worry at the moment

I dont disagree, whatever structure that is used, if it isnt worked at, it will fail, and if the people tasked with doing that work arent capable, then they should be replaced

Let's go back to one division all clubs in it. Get rid of full time rugby go back to semi professional. All matches to kick off at 3pm on a Saturday. Season to last from September to May. Last match of season Challenge Cup final at Wembley.
Oh and get rid of RL board & sky tv.

too much my backside there used to be the County Cups The JPS the Floodlight the CC and 16 clubs in the old first division it was a better game to watch and we had skilled centres stand offs scrum halfs and loose forwards
Too much rugby who are you Jamie Peacock lol

Good idea, lets also forget the wheel and go back to living in mud huts and trading goats.