Scott girx since coming back has been terrible do you think we should leave him out of the squad of sell him.

What to you think to frank

i think thats a very bold 2nd post statement ......



edited

i think it might be better for some if you back up this suggestion. sorry if the original post came across a little bit ratty . just had my fill with negativity.

I am a 10950 + poster and i still have no credibility so i would not hold your breath for a response!!!

Terrible is a bit harsh for Grix but he is certainly off form as are the rest of the team. The key to Grix i feel is finding a set position for him that he is comfortable with, i do not think he is a wingman by any stretch, and personally feel he needs a run at 1 or 6, but does he deserve one at the moment? Probably not.

Not seen much of Frank but from what i have seen he has been steady at best, but as i say i am basing that on very little exposure so not really in a position to give a full valid opinion.

glad it isnt just me who thought the first reply was abit off.

would be harsh to judge grix as has been playing out of position and before he got injured was playin his best stuff in the middle of the park not out on the wings.

not sure on frank as we havent seen much of him tbh. why not have im running at the oposition centres with his siz, we would have more joy.

but thats only my opinion, not sure if its credible or not as i have'nt posted much

For starters how can not answer someone because its there second post that means were not welcoming other wakefield fans on to the forum!!! And how the hell can you say sell someone because they'vea few bad games if you attend games and notice he actually trys his all every gamehe's always one of the ones chasing back etc play him in position and i feel he can replicate the form he showed in the world cup!! Somehow i dont thing we'd be shouting for the boot if it was broughy, blanchy or blaymire having a few of games. As for frank, kear must see something in him or he wouldnt have come over here for reserve grade football as far as i'm aware e just needs match fitness and to get used to the match plan etc .......... or was he just recommened by Willie Poaching!!!

]



maybe im being cynical but im a little curious as to why someone joins a forum just to be negative from the start. i would try to explain my self a little more in depth but at this moment in time im sick to the back teeth of people just slating players who put 100% into the club whilst so call heroes and top earners do nothing but drag our club through the gutter.

yes they are allowed an opinion as am i .

The problem for Grix as I see it is that since coming back from injury, is that he has had to get a game wherever he can because of other players' coming back into the team. He is obviously suffering from a loss of confidence and imo the wing is not the place to try and play yourself back in and maybe he is trying a bit too hard and by making mistakes' he is just compounding his problem. Maybe a couple of games in the reserves' might do him the world of good.

I feel sorry for Grix, he was one of our best performing players before he got injured and since then, as everyone has mentioned, he's struggled to get a game in a poistion he feels comfortable in.

He's clearly not a winger, but you can never doubt his commitment to the cause. He always gives 100%, and never backs away!

I'd be tempted to maybe give him a couple of academy games to get some form back then when he's got his confidence back slowly bring him back into the first team.

He's clearly a class player, we've saw that in the world cup/start of the season. I think he just needs to be moved away from the wing!

In terms of Winterstein, i don't think we've seen the best of him yet...but i expect him to get better. He's a big unit and i think once hegets to full fitness and in tuen with the rest of the team he could be a good addition!

Keep em both - they'll both come good.

i think grix will get better, although i think he inst too good on the wing. And for frankie, think he will do better as the season progresses.

Although it may seem unfair at times on new posters, we have had problems before with banned members logging in under different names, we are wary at times because of this, and besides if they can't take a knockback they won't last long anyway


Welcome Wakeysam, choose your side.

Carry on Jonh

My posts keep being deleted from this thread with no reason why, anybody know?

This is my third one now, is my credibility score low also??

expect to see this one go shortly

you can log on under an alias with a diffo name, easy to do