Providing the players a fit this is the way id go

1,minns- outstanding for reserves other night at fb
2,murphy -hes got talent in abundance
3,hall- as per purphy
4, croft-quality player and lynne out of form
5,kaye -most consistent for me
6, miller - best we have
7, lino,
8,arona-if every player worked as hard as him we wouldnt be where we are
9,hood
10,buttler - see what he got
11,pitts
12,kelepi -please let him play in pos he is best and got in dream team
13 walker.pays well every game

14, fiffita pur best forward use to impact
15,yusef
16,Batchelor
17,lineham-to move kaye to 9

We’ve nothing to lose Luppylad putting that team out ,we need a big shake up ,only one I’d swap is Hood for Bowes ,the lad seems much faster at the play the ball and to counter the threat from Dwyer who will have a field day if we don’t step up the intensity in our defence . But what have we to lose ,I’d rather see us go down fighting with lads that want to play for us than a bunch of half hearted blokes that look like they have no desire to put the effort in for the fans or the shirt .

Why not, let's face it we're hardly breaking up a winning team.

It's right what they say players play better on paper Minnus in for MJ is a belter I ham right in thinking that in a reserve game Gaskell set up 5 trys ,so why does he look so bad in the first team .One answer as been the first team do not no how to read him .So the reserve must then

Jowitt
Johnstone
Hall
Lyne (very tempted to put Minns in)
Murphy
Miller
Lino
Fifita
Hood
Arona
Tanginoa
Batchelor
Whitbread

Battye
Kay
Walker (to interchange at 13).
Butler

Just watched the Salford v Leeds highlights , no rockets science from Salford just players running into gaps at pace ,offloads and second faze looking relatively simple when you watch the moves develop ,but it’s pretty alien to us for some reason .Leeds looked like rabbits in the headlights trying to stem the breaches , it’s certainly going to be entertaining for possibly all the wrong reasons when we clash on Fri . Leeds are certainly low on confidence but unfortunately so are we ,and all will depend on who has their heads in the right place and wants it more to take the spoils. It’s definitely a battle of the basement clubs and we’ll never get a better chance ,but I’ve heard that somewhere before .

If making sweeping changes was the correct way to go:

Max (Despite my criticism, he’s 100% committed)
Murphy
Croft
Hall
TJ (if he’s still a WT player
Walker
Lino
Fifita
Bowes
Butler (should be eager to stand out)
Batchelor
Tanginoa
Arona

Kay
Shaw/Eseh
Aydin
Whitbread

Just as it was when we gave them their first win of the season!!
Let's hope this time around we can show some guts and desire!!!!

Seriously suggesting dropping Jowitt one of the best and most committed players in a very poor squad
Sorry but no I would probably make him captain and this may help Miller.
Definitely a case for dropping Lyne who has done nothing in months.
Please play props at 8-10 and put Tanginoa 2nd row and Arona at loose

Think I’d rather see Whitbread at loose but I’d definitely be down for some changes in the team.
Tanginoa and Batch in second row.
Whitbread at 13.
There are options and we can’t keep going with the same forwards without shaking things up.

We all have our preferred starting 13 and subs ,and the truth is anyone of those combinations may work better than what we have at the moment . Some of our players for whatever reason aren’t committed enough to the cause , and they need to step aside until such time as their mojo comes back.Poaching could do with ringing the changes for this Fridays clash and see how things pan out , you never know we may get 17 players busting a gut and working as a team .

If Reece Lyne is surplus to requirements could we have him please.

Jowitt is constantly at fault for trys ie 2 v toulouse and the attack stops when it goes to him.he ok under a high ball.

It's nice that we can all pick our own preferred 17, and have our opinions on how the team should be balanced...but we have no idea at all of what state, particularly physically, each of the players is in.

We certainly don't have a healthy squad and appear to have quite a few "walking wounded".

Is our best 17 really the worst in SL, if and when fit??

Apart from the pass he sent to Kay for his try the Toulouse game?