After the Cas game we got talking about how well this squad have performed.
I'm delighted with our season I was a bit negative about us and really expected us to be in the bottom four (tin hat on), however, we then got onto strengthening.
I couldn't really think (with our financial constraints) of the positions we could really improve, my only addition would be a real good quality hooker, but at the back of my mind I keep thinking of the old adage if you stay still you go backwards.
So....Who would you replace position wise (sensibly) or add to the squad for next season?

I guess it depends who's available. Don't think there's a specific position that needs strengthening other than maybe a top class hooker or centre, but should probably just be a case of if someone becomes available within our budget that would improve us then sign them.

Agree with the hooker centre positions to strengthen obviously within our means.. would love to see a centre like dean collis. Who could utilise the class we have on both wings..also a top out and out hooker to take advantage of fifitas quick play the balls and also to steady things down when need...not slating woody think hes had a cracking season..just think we need to just keep pushing on to the next level

We probably need to look at a replacement for Finn.
He has been superb this season but, he isn't getting any younger.
Most people though that Williams would fit the bill and maybe, with 12 months at under his belt and assuming he stays, the perhaps he can take on "Finn role" but, I'm not sure.
Having said that good half backs are very difficult to find and maybe managing Finn's game time will be a better option for next season.
Some cover at 9, would also be high on the shopping list and another guy called Fifita would be a bonus

Hooker
Stand off
Big second row that can pass to centres

Same as most teams then!

Yes
That's the trouble

We are in such a great position at the mo with our first team
Our first team is exception and we've got great cover in the squad

If Randal comes in and works out all we need is some one to replace williams ideally some one with a danny brough style kicking game I'd be over the moon

Carter and the coaching team have done an amazing job putting our team together

Clearly a quality nine would add a lot to us...Woody done brilliant but can't expect him to play 80 minutes every week and a shared role with a better nine would be great...he could also offer decent cover in the halves...

Happy with our two full backs but would love to see a lot more of Jowitt next season...happy with the three quarters too..

Props very happy with...size, power and aggression and as good as any set of props in the league for me...

Backrow id love to see us sign a blockbuster type player...something in the mound on BMM at Salford...a Solomona, Big Ali type player...am almost certain we'll lose Hadley back to Hull as he's far too good a player for them to let go and Kirmond will be a year older...we've Batchelor to fill the void but he's still very young for a forward and although I'd like to see much more of him next season, I don't want to see too much of him if that makes sense...

Might be worth looking at championship too to maybe unearth a project player or two to maintain strength in depth..

In all seriousness, I think the experiment with Hirst is done and won't be repeated, it would imo have been announced that he'd re-signed. Algood just hasn't been fit enough to prove his worth, so that's 1 or 2 props that need replacing. Kirmond is coming to the end of his tenure, injuries taking a while to get over etc. Good player but to improve we need to be a bit ruthless. Up and coming half to learn from Finn. Hooker to work with Wood, I really like our main centres of toupu and lynn, I'd have kept Gibson rather than Arundel, but that ship has sailed. So a couple of props, a starting second row, hooker and a half. Top 4 next year.

Thought Hirst was signed for next season?

I think he's gone quite well...nothing spectacular but decent for his first season in the top flight...he's a big presence...doesn't make many mistakes and is a handful to bring down...more often than not gets a decent play the ball too...

I think he'll improve again next year....

Not sure on Allgood...we aint seen enough yet....he's a quota spot though which means when he gets back in for the super 8's he's a player who really needs to put his hand up and show he's worth that quota place...Fifita, Huby and Walker are all comfortably ahead of him for me...England and Hirst about similar on what i've seen....so as I say he needs a big end to the season...

Hirst is good for 2 dropped balls a game. Can't afford it if we want to push on.

He's only made 5 errors all season looking at his stats?

The one the other night I'd hardly blame him for either...what halfback at first receiver on the last tackle passes along the line to a prop forward!

Hirst has being an exceptional signing for us, a john kear signing at its best I'd say

Hirst, Grix, Wood, MCB, Huby, Walker have all being better than I think any of us could have hoped for

Williams has being the only signing who hasn't exceeded my expectations though he has being competent

For me carter's greatest signing of all is John Kear