Hasn't been banned! It wasn't a ban IMO but he plays in the same side as Scott Moore so anything was possible!

apart from a semi good game in the QF has been terrible as expected all the other games- MC do not resign for next year!

Too much sun, my old mucker, I watched the game back last night and he put decent shift in and looked like he was up for it, I suggest you have a look at the games a bit more closely

So wrong.

Does this include the near 70 minute shift he put in against Cas where he was possibly our best forward?

He has put some big minutes in during a few of the games he has featured.

Also, I feel that since the quarter final, he has been very closely looked after by the opposition. That said, he is still drawing several players with him into the tackle, and looks dangerous every time.

I hope we do re sign him, and with him, England, added in with the rumours of Cox and Green coming, we could have a very large front row next year. Not to mention Simon, who although smaller, when fit runs the ball in as hard as anyone.

Just remind us when it was that you last watched Trinity.
He has been our best "go forward" prop since he signed and by some distance.
He made a couple of errors on debut by trying to force offloads but, you really need to watch some games.

I think you may be posting on the wrong forum

By the way, Trinity are in the top 8 (I think that you had us all but relegated previously)

If you ignore his first game against Leeds where I think he was trying a bit too hard to impress which is not the worst thing in the world then I think he has done good.

The Huddersfield game was his best but he has had to play some big minutes in other games due to the amount of injuries which means that he wasn't as explosive as he was against Huddersfield.

I don't think you could question his effort or commitment in the games he has played and for me we should be doing our very best to keep him.

I thought he ran his blood to water against us to be honest, and for long minutes. If that game was anything to go by you should be looking at trying to keep him not moving him out.

Only really seen him against Cas and he showed plenty of effort and enthusiasm. Seemed a decent bloke as well and had a bit of fun with the Cas fans.

One semi good game = MOM in our first CC win against a SL side in 12 years.
You've already told everyone you live in Australia so you clearly haven't been to any games this season and base your opinions on nothing. Do everyone on here a favour and stop filling the board with absolute garbage.

Think BOJ04 should redirect his criticism towards Scruton who , aside from Catalans, has been disappointing since his return from injury.

We should be signing him up for next year - and trying to persuade him to get his brother over an all; he's a destructive, difficult to stop forward, with a tidy offload - which drags the opposition defence out of shape and puts the willies up tacklers. We haven't had that for a while and with good support runners like Miller and Jowitt and working with him for a full pre-season, he could be really dangerous.

He's been good, hope he decides to stay on.