Didn't look too bad for his debut, hope he replaces Vievers next week against Bradford.

Without another Gledhill episode, looked strong, did not get dominated and good defence.

Can't ask more for his debut. Big off season for the lad and then he may be pushing for a spot behind Murphy, Mellars.

Ran over the top of the first defender on a couple of occasions and took some pulling down, he certainly didn't look like he needs protecting.

Didn't look out of place due to his size. Can't help thinking he would have made is debut long ago in many other Super League sides.

1. Tony
2. Tongia
3. Walshaw
4. Tadulala
5. Morton

He looked strong and certainly didn't look out of his depth. I would like to see him given a starting place next week but even if he doesn't play then he has a bright future with the club.

I'm no expert, but I've seen this kid a few times this season and been very impressed with him - used properly, he could have a similar impact in the first team next season as some of the young stars at other clubs; I'm looking forward to watching him.

1. Tongia - the guy is a fb give him a chance there
2. Semi
3. Tony - probably the best non specialised centre we have
4. Walshaw - self explanatory
5. Morton

Some people may swap the centres but I'd personally like to see how those two go together as one for the future.

Think Semi will be struggling to be fit, the last two matches he's gone off just after halftime will a hamstring pull.

Went well for his first game...was stood near his family and friends and they were really nervous - but the boy did good...playing in front of the south stand is a big test of nerve and he came through it and did a couple of nice runs..

Very good debut, looks strong and confident. Should have been on at half time at the latest. Team mates looked like they had confidence in him too looking to get the ball in his hands regularly. Hope he starts against Bradford then has a big pre season and is raring to go in 2012.

All things being equal, Semi should be nowhere near the squad next season.

Before he came back I would have agreed however I think he has done a very good job for us and as his wages wont be massive me may be a decent squad player next year although if there are better options available then I wouldn't be upset if he did go.

Agree its time to move on from Semi. He has helped us out this year but I think the evidence is showing that the body is telling him that his time in top level rugby is up.

Good debut. Certainly not overawed, should be in next week.