Back to walmsley and Atoni - I know somebody has to go to make way for Smoothy, and I reckon it's a sign of where we are now that we are letting a player of such quality go.
Not everybody's cup of tea, but I rate Walmsley.
To me he's as good a finisher as TJ.
I don't buy into the business of him not good enough or big enough to drive the ball up.
Tommy Makinson is similar but it hasn't stopped him being a top winger for years.
I like Atoni, and it seems DP rates him too.
Unfortunately somebody has to be a coach and I'm pleased he's making the decision not me!

Agree would always take a good winger who as pace to burn to finish of moves ,than a winger who can clear is line ,.In defence speed is important, as in getting across to defend .Think lack of speed as cost us two games .I like Atoni  as well Mr Powell as not got a lot wrong but it looks like he as some big calls to make

Alas a modern winger has to do both.


If you don't get off the line you won't have field position to score the tries.


I'd happily keep Lacky but there are a lot of English wingers around that could replace him.
Not the same for every position.