not bad for a little fat waster

You do talk some rubbish try scorer, trying to figure out if you are a WUM or you actually believe some of the stuff you come out with.

I guess it does not take much to impress Wane, Maguire and Lam either, they all pick him out as one of the best forwards in a team that has been one of the best in the league for some years, 3 dream team appearances, 4 grand final rings and he certainly hasn't slowed down this season.

Out of interest who would you have had in the second row alongside Kelepi? Or has he been rubbish as well?

Oh it does old cock. I am impressed by your stupidity, its outstanding

I'm not sure why people are saying they should or shouldn't be in.

The players are not chosen on the night, it is a culmination of man of the match points over the season.
If McShane is awarded more man of the match points than anyone else, then he wins.

Oh dear, there you go again, making a fool of yourself...please tell me where I have slagged Cas off in that post ???
I apologise most sincerely for having an opinion that is different to yours and will try not to do it again....I'm so sorry, oh wise one

So, despite being castigated by "tryscorer" (look it up if you need to - old cock), I am still sticking with French as my Man of Steel, so, whilst accepting PT's point that McShane was awarded the most man of the match points over the season, IF it had been awarded as per previous seasons, by voting, who would people have chosen out of the 5 contenders - French, Coote, McShane, Farrell or Sezer ??