My age allows me to put Geoff Gerrard on the list, different type of player but went on to the International stage after having spell at Wakefield. That wouldn't happen now.

That's an interesting comparison.

I don't think there is a position in RL which has two more contrasting styles than the centres. In this case you've picked the two extremes.

In Miles you have a TRY MAKER

In Meninga a GAME BREAKER.

Yet both IMHO are equally as valid

If TJ had Miles as a centre he'd score 30+ a season in a decent Trinity side. Miles not that many.

If TJ had Meninga he'd score half that but the partnership would probably score the same.

The only difference is that Meninga would chip a lot of individual match winning wonder tries that Miles wouldn't - so this IMHO gives Meninga quite an the edge.

Miles = 101 games 20 tries (but countless assists)

Meninga = 306 games 189 tries Speaks for itself really.

There off Wikipedia. I think the Meninga ones are but the Miles ones I agree look a tad on the mean side.

It doesn't include his tries for Wigan either.