I think you'll find thar might be a team defence issue as much as anything. I'm not saying Grix didn't have issues on Sunday because he certainly did, but it's a big leap of faith to say Max would have faired any better. Of course he might have had a blinder, who knows, all I know is that CC and JK will have picked the best players available from the squad to win the game.

We all quite rightly have opinions but the coaches are working on better information than us speccies, so you have to have faith with them, especially considering the position they have put the club in and the quality of rugby they have us generally playing. Nothing wrong with a healthy and reasonable debate about selection issues though

Trinity may well have been in the vanguard of this trend of wingers taking the first couple of runs. Go back 4 or 5 years when Cockayne and Foxy were doing this. With good effect too.

Last season I thought Jowitt could potential become our equivalent Jamie Shaul. Couldn't help being reminded of that watching his try scoring in today's semi.

Thought exactly the same myself during yesterdays game.

He's quite fast but he's not Jamie Shaul fast.

Difficult to prove I know, and probably not over the first few yards but once in full flight I think Max might just have the edge.