Michael Dobson has signed for Salford... www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/27867146 May help our chances of retaining Tim Smith

Michael Dobson has signed for Salford... www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/27867146 May help our chances of retaining Tim Smith

Why do you consider him to be quality because the games I have seen him plays he makes more mistakes than I have ever seen Mathers make. I suppose the fact he went from Castleford to Huddersfield, to Hull KR, to Salford on loan and back to Hull KR I think indicates that he is a long long way from being the finished full back.

I just like his flair in attack, who's saying that full back is his role anyway

as you say he keeps getting knocked of that pedestal with the odd mistake but I'd know who'd I'd select between the two

Don't forget Eden played in our academy before going to Cas.....

I'd pick Mathers which tells you what i think of Eden. The kid can be elusive going forward no doubt but he makes at least one horrendous error a game that tends to lead to the opposition scoring. And this is has been happening for a number of season now under a range of different coaches which tends to tell me he hasn't got it between the ears either. I'd steer well clear to be honest.

Yep, I get what Snowie means but I don't think he will ever get rid of the errors - he'd be a worse version of Mathers who just runs the wrong way faster. I mean yo never lose hope but for now he's more Forrest Gump than Billy Slater.