In a 'the op must have be psychic with a thread title like that' kind of way... I still think it's a good system and the best fit for our sport. Charlie & I are happy
Franchising can only work if you have more clubs meeting the minimum requirements than there are places in the league (we have about 5 who can break even as professional clubs). The idea that somehow that system can promote growth and expansion has been proven to be a fallacy. There are no Bristol millionaires itching to buy an RL franchise.
Automatic P & R = boom and bust, failed before, will fail again, same story, not enough money in the game.
Some say it's too complicated/convoluted, but it's no more so than the current play-off system.
Some say there will be meaningless games, again, no more than the current set up where often your play-off hopes are ended half way through a 27 game season. And even if you make 7th/8th, it's usually just one extra game. The top clubs know they can make the 8 playing at half pace. A shorter first part of the season will reduce this a little.
The problem of playing championship rugby for half the season not being attractive is exaggerated to the extreme. The 8's are only a third of the season and only 2 clubs from the current championship will be taking part. (assuming Bradford and London (& us?) make it that far).
If you think games with Fev and Fax against Wakey, Cas, Bradford, London, Widnes and, say, HKR won't be competitive when there's something real to play for, then prepare to lose. Factor in a cashed-up Toulouse and you've got a decent mini comp.
No system is perfect and can produce cup final rugby every round, but at least there's a sporting angle to playing in the top flight and hope for the lower placed or new clubs.
It is unlikely that anything will change at first in the top 12, particularly with the extra 4th/5th play-off giving any top 12 club a second bite of the cherry, but at least the opportunity is there. If you're not good enough to be in the top 12 after playing your peers, then so be it. You can always try again the next year.