Noble is going to Bradford...the problem is he has lost the respect of the players! There is nothing there our defence is pants our attack consists of 3 moves and the effort is appalling. How long are people going to put up with it? The Catalan game was good for the first half but we nearly gave it away in the second. I am sick of excuses and sick of his crap team selections.

It's just not good enough by agar or the players

In my opinion its more so the players than Agar. In all fairness to the bloke some of the better signings are down to him and the poor ones someone else. For instance he did a good bit of business sending Tommy Lee to Shudds and getting Wood. Like wise our only good overseas players Collis and Aiton are also his.

I think where people have a genuine gripe are in two basic areas.

1. His technical knowledge of the game may be good but he may lack the communication skills to pass it on to the players and motivate them. I really believe if Glenn Morrison had not suffered that injury and was still captain at the club his leadership on the field would have rubbed off on to the team and Agar would be having a much better time.

2. He is frustrating the supporters by appearing too loyal to non performing players and sticking to some baffling tactics. He has probably given somethings a little more time than they deserve. However the blokes hands are tied over the Easter period due to the amount and intensity of the fixtures. I will judge the bloke on this one when I see what he selects from the available players once this period is over.


I think giving him 3 years was madness. However I also think its too early to make a decision, therefore not voting on this one yet.

Give over, that's like Captain_Library saying he's Ollie Elima.

No point voting. Good or bad; it's done and that's all there is

Overall i don't rate him but he probably deserves the chance to prove himself for a bit longer yet. But if the same problems still persist in 6 or 7 weeks time my patience will have worn very thin. For me he's got until we play cas at the Etihad on magic weekend to show that he is improving us.

Well for me I was willing to give Agar the benefit knowing what his former boss is like with the husband.It does appear that Agar is running out of ideas and time lets face it we have a side that should be doing well.Good win over Widnes a good game against KR that with a bit more luck could have gone our way.A great first half v Bradford and should have been in front but rubbish second half.To come away from the KC 14 - 10 with the defending we had to do was good.Hudds game didnt let any one down.Warrington a real good go and so near so far.Catalan great first half then hung on for win.London and Cas what the heavens happened that was total rubbish.Then todays game he drops Smith and keeps John well for me Smiths been the better of the two by some way.It wont be long before the shouts for him out will gain more momentum and the non season ticket fans go do other things.

things were looking good up until the london game, so we have shown good potential. But it seams like in the last 3 games that no ones really that bothered any more (although i didnt go to wigan, but we cant say we didnt expect to get beat!). Somethings obviously not quite right in the changing room

Chill out, give him time.

Excellent post imo.

Smith was nursing a few knocks, thats why he didn't play les goose

Just posted something similar in the Steve Southern thread.