Quote Slugger McBatt="Slugger McBatt"I don't like finding myself in a position of defending another team's player over one of ours, but I am sticking up for Dobson, not putting Broughy down.
As KR finished above us, your argument doesn't seem the strongest. Dobson is a very good player, and consistent with it, and unlikely to cost a game (or be suspended for one) due to a brainstorm. I would have Dobson in a Wakey shirt in a heartbeat. Also, surely a prop can be measured in stats, as that is the job of a prop, yards and tackles.
Also, looking at that dream team, if that is a measure of form, looks like a Leeds-v-Hull KR final.'"
Ok, so because KR finished one place above the Wildcats, that makes Dobson a better player than Brough?!
Furthermore, see Bloomers point re: tackle statistics - I'm still waiting for an apology for your previous sardonic comment.
Dobson is an excellent player, no shadow of a doubt and is worthy of being a contender or even a spot in the dream team. What I will say is that I rate Brough more highly and he is defensively better, as the stats (contrary to your previous post) quantify.