He's nothing like Scholes.

Modric and Ireland, while not clones of Scholes, are much more like Ginge than Rodwell.

I never said he was.

The point was the Scholes is in his last season imo and I think Rodwell would sit very nicely in Utd's midfield alongside with Carrick or Anderson.

I've said all along that Rodwell could go as far as he wants to go in the game...he seems to have everything going for him in the modern game...maybe he will be the longer-term replacement for Lescott?? I think most Everton observers see him as a centre-half eventually...still at not much older than 18 years old he needs game time at the minute to build his experience and staying at Everton will give him that

And chances would be created out of....fresh air?

Fella, you do come across as clueless when it comes to United.

Well if he is available I'm sure we would take him off your hands

What can I say, I probably don't have the same obsession with Utd as you do!

Either way I would be happy if we were to sign Rodwell although I very much doubt we will.

Hull City chairman Paul Duffen claims Alvaro Negredo had agreed to move to the KC Stadium before Real Madrid sold the striker to Sevilla

what a load of $hit you talk duffen

He could well have done.

I think Hull should be given some credit for trying to sign a good player from outside the Prem. It would have been an expensive risk but they were prepared to do it. Fair play, I say.

Regardless, I still don't like Phil Brown

I don't think I've ever seen two posts posted so close together that contradict one another as much as these.