Bad challenges happen in sports issue most fans have is with the referee and the RFL disciplinary panel as 1 week its a ban the next week its not. Mcilorum got sent off by the Video ref telling the ref what had happened. Someone on another forum who is on here as well listened in on it via maybe dubious methods. Whilst this weekend it just got put on report.

When this happens you got to question what is going on. It can not carry on 1 rule this week another the next as it its atm in SL.

I don't know anything about the mcillurom ban and conspiracies.

Could say the same about Paul wood in the cup final and kylie last week one got a ban one didnt

For the record we don't what will happen with McGuire yet.

Rugby god's forbid we should mention his name....

I agree with you and that what most on here are getting at.

Very sad

Shame Clarke didn't mention them in the exiles game, when leulali broke his leg trying to stop a try illegally.

Hopefully it's because he learnt his lesson and not because of his bias nature.

I'm sure people were earlier saying it was wrong to compare similar events... Incidentaly, if you ARE comparing, was Mr M trying to stop a try illegally, and thus cheating... Just looking for clarity from you..

Maybe you should wait and see what happens.

I am not comparing the events I am just wondering what your opinion on similar events is you seem to believe in the rugby gods. We're they at work then?

No you did... i just said that we should not mention him.... You made comparisons... I asked for clarity on your thoughts.

So you don't mention McGuire because of the rugby gods, do you mention leulali ??

You raised that, not i.. And i asked you for clarification, as to whether you thought that BOTH were cheating?

Comparing incidents I think the one by Myler on one of the Hull wingers was closer to MM than Mcguires. Was I the only person to think that Myler could have pulled out of the challenge and also raised his elbow?

We have different perspectives I don't wish injury on any player of any club.

Are you implying i do?