A watertight post that sums up the situation perfectly.

Regards Charnley he seems to be a very exciting prospect that I feel should be loaned out next year but with a weeks recall notice should we have any injuries to our starting centres as he for me on his current showing he has earned the right to be considered as our first back up centre for 2011, and if he continues to perform has earned the right to take Georges shirt outright in 2012.

I don't think we will have a problem loaning him out. Hull KR will have him and if they won't have him, Crusaders, Salford, Cas, Wakey, Quins.... would be stupid not to take him on.

How did a "wire troll" derial it? I was praising Charnley and the club if you cared to read the initial post. As for replacing Gleeson, Charnley has been playing right centre hasn't he? It was a Wigan fan who then turned it into a dick measuring contest and started abusing Mathers. I even joked about his comedy forward rolls, he fulfilled a purpose in a position we had a need for. Would be a good idea to get your facts right first instead of having a pop for no reason.

Rubbish, you knew by bringing Gleeson into the topic that it would start the whole Mathers/Gleeson dispute in which you carried on posting further on about it and brought up the whole boring issue of him having a challenge cup winners medal. Charnley has been playing right centre but his main position is wing, only reason why Hull KR haven't used him as a winger is because that isn't where they have an injury crisis currently.

Only because all our centres and some wingers are out injured, otherwise he would of been sat doing naff all in your reserves - shouldnt you be loaning more of your players out to gain experience and show how good they are?

I for one would only play him until we have our players back, would rather give our players the experience of another season of playoff rugby, then your youngsters.

Most of them are, or have been except when we've needed to recall them because of our own injuries. Our current U20's side is made up of mostly U18 players.

Well on that note id say your looking at a bright few years at/near the top.

As anyone made the headlines like Charnley has?

Apart from Mossop, Tomkins x2, Farrell, Tuson, and Marsh erm no.

Cheers

Wigan KR final it is then!

Not at all. Seeing as I ain't a follower of Wigan's youth system is fair to assume that he'd be right centre in the future, not a mark on Gleeson at all. I think you need to stop being paranoid.