As above with doc murray and robbie Mccormack he played number 9.

Over rated? The man was a fantastic player!

Past Howard came with a shed load of hype and was garbage, current Joel Tomkins but i hope he steps up to the plate to realise his great potential under a new coach.

Across the league Roby.

Stunned to see the likes of Newlove and Schofield mentioned, both fantastic players.

Can anybody remember a player 1-7 think he played either full back/wing late 1990s with a funny name and aussie.

You seriously think Mccormack was over rated? Watch that Leeds match back from 98 when he got took out in the first few minutes i remember thinking about how much we lacked direction when he was not on. He was one of the most UNDER RATED players we have ever had within the super league era, despite only being here for a season

Andre Stoop? Although he was a Saffy.

Agree the bloke was huge for us despite his stature. I would give my right nut for a player as good as him running our rucks this year.

He was paul kolia or something like that

Paul Koloi signed on the recommendation of Faz after the Toyota 7's, absolutely garbage!

LMAO, Mccormack or the pig you decide

Andy Coley for mine.

Luke Davico? all 15 mins of a friendly

Because Feka plays 20-30 minutes a game and the last couple of seasons he's been very inconsistent, makes many errors in defence that many of our fans don't see for some reason but are easy to start chanting his name evey time he takes the ball up, cringe! He's a good player when on form but he's vastly overrated at our club by some of our fans. That's what this thread is about!

Simple, ask Peacock & Monaghan, because everytime he comes on they point, smile and run straight at him. He is overated by us more than he is by our opposition's fans. As for not swapping Feka for another prop in SL, I would have (top of my head), Peacock, Leuluai, Graham, Carvell, LMS, Crabtree, Ryles, Guissett, Lynch, Mason. Can't think of any more now it's a little late. Eamon O' Carroll too I would start him instead of Feka.
Finished.

Damn missed out Morley. Now I really do need to go.

Seriously I’d love some of what you’re on pal.

I’ll stand by my post that the only prop in SL I’d take over Feka is Graham as he’s the only player that comes close to having the potential Feka has.

Leuluai, Carvell, Crabtree, LMS, O’Carroll, Gussiett, Mason & Ryles are miles behind Feka imo. You only need to look at the meters, tackle busts and off loads an unfit Feka has made this season with his limited ‘substitutions by the clock’ to see he’s in a different class to the others.

Everyone bleats on about how players like Bailey and Fielden are undervalued because of the work they get through and how their defence is quality but don’t take into consideration the other aspects of their game? Yes they are good defensive players (not quality btw as that’s what I’d class players like Hindmarsh as) but they don’t offer us a whole lot else bar experience?

Now Feka isn’t the best defensive player out there but he is one of the best impact props in SL if not THE best out there and this is with him being unfit to boot.

People speak about how we should swap Feka with this or that prop but if we were to lose Feka then I’d shudder to think what our go forward would be like.