The surprising inclusion of Ferres to start worked well, Westwood has too many pens in him, at international level he is a liability. Mossop lacked impact Hill and Burgess should stay as starting props, next week

Tomkins
Charnley
Cudjoe
Watkins
Hall
Chase
Sinfield
Burgess
Roby
Hill
Ferres
Burgess
OLoughlin

Burgess, Farrell, Graham, Burrow

Sam Burges and Graham to start for me with George off the bench.

I'd take a gamble in the backs and get Sam at #6. At the end of the day he's better than the current option in Chase and is our only true world class back. Get his hands on the ball as much as we can and see where we go from there!

At the end of the day apart from Sam our backs aren't good enough and won't create the extra space Sam needs to be effective. At least with Sam at HB he's going to cause the defence questions.

I can see the temptation to move Tompkins to stand off, it's been called for with Wigan.

The game against Ireland is the perfect time to try it, they are the weakest team in the group.

You could make a case for Widdop as that's his chosen position but with him only just coming back from injury there has to be question marks over him.

Sam for me would just give us something different and a bit of x-factor that's needed to take the game to the Australians. He has the potential to be a mercurial talent on the lines of a Benji Marshall at the last world cup.

Agree with regard to Tomkins he just wasn't getting any kind of service, which is a shame because he looked dangerous whenever he touched the ball. I do prefer S.Burgess at prop because he seems to get far more involved from there but I'd like to keep the other 2 Burgess', Hill and Graham in there so I'd go:

1. Widdop
2. Charnley
3. Watkins
4. Cudjoe
5. Hall
6. Tomkins
7. Sinfield
8. Graham
9. McIlorum
10. Hill
11. S.Burgess
12. Westwood
13. O'Loughlin

14. G.Burgess
15. T.Burgess
16. Farrell
17. Roby

McIlorum to batter them about for the first 10-15 of each half then Roby to send people through the spaces their tired legs can't cover. One can dream anyway! If Tomkins at 6 and Widdop at 1 isn't working swap them around, keep them guessing

Briscoe may be better (in your opinion) but Charnley's main strength is finishing and scoring try's. He's like how Jimmy Greaves used to play in footie in the early 1960's.

I know of not one Wigan fan who would have Briscoe in our team over Charnley, and i'd confidently say you made that up

I don't think there's a full back in world rugby league who Inglis wouldn't have out jumped for that try. England need to learn to pressure the kickers better.

I don't think Mossop had his best game but for me he was better than Tom Burgess. I'd start Graham and Hill with Sam Burgess in the 2nd row and Lockers at loose. Widdop should be at 6 with consistent halves for 80 minutes. Roby is an 80 minute hooker, I'd use mcilorum and burrow in games against lesser nations but against oz and NZ it should be Widdop and Sinfield at 6 and 7 with roby at 9 and 4 forwards on the bench.

Did,nt westwood hit one of aussie forwards high early on in the first half? Can,t which player he hit though.

Can,t remember which player he hit high though.

My Team for Ireland

Tomkins
Charnley
Watkins
Cudjoe
Hall
Widdop
Chase
Hill
McIllorum
Graham
Farrell
Westwood
O'Loughlin (c)

Bench

Roby
Ferres
G. Burgess
T. Burgess

Got to agree with this.

Westwood was spot on in sticking up for Tomkins.

Not for the first time either. He belted someone a few years back in the Exiles game after Sam caught a cheap one

Anyone moaning that a British forward tried to smack an Antipodean needs their head looking at.

Agreed, we need a few lads who will stick it to them and do abit of housing just like Greg Bird does for them.

I like that side of Westwoods game, he just need to be a little more astute and sly when he's doing it so he doesn't give any penalties away.

That is a great team selection but I can not see him leaving Sinfield out.

Do any of them qualify for Ireland?