So thats what you teach is it? his arm was under Richards neck with the full wight of his body behind him now thats a high shot in my books try looking at it again. Had it been the other way round the lad would have found himself with at least a yellow and knowing our luck a red.

Probably the silliest post you have ever made Jonh. Watch the replay.

Watched it a few times. I would have been very dissapointed had one of our players come up with this play and been penalised for it.

Really? Where? Give em a bl00dy game then!!

Agreed. Looked bad at first but he went up for the ball and didn't get it so went for the player who did. Your not allowed to tackle someone who's in the air but that was more the other way round. It was unusual, but not a penalty offence.

So it wasn't a head high tackle then?

I would say it was 2 players comitted to the play, which should be applauded not penalised.

Phelps on Wellens on Thursday with the last play of the game was just as bad if not filled with more intent on Phelps part, did not see many complaints in here.

So you don't think it was a head high tackle?


Yes or no will do.

Clearly not, no.

For someone who claims to be such an intellect i thought you would have worked that one out.


Are youn still looking forward to reviving all the posts about how poor us mortals think Noble is at the end of the season?

Yes or no will do.

I've always stuck up for Noble but now i think it's time for him to move on. He has done a terrific job here, keeping us in the Super League and almost getting us to the Grand Final etc. But i think we have to get rid for us to develop as a team and a club. IMO our defence has been poor everytime we have taken the field since Millward took over, with the odd exception of course (Leeds in the CC etc), and we need to add another dimension to our attacking play. Im sick of Wigan being the only team in SL to have no runners trying to confuse the opposition.

Well......thats my two cents anyway

I don't claim to have anything. It's only you who keeps banging on about me being "such an intellect" (whatever that means). Indeed now it appears you think I am some kind of Deity..........

I personally don't think BN will be here by the end of the season, but if he is I still think we will perform well in the playoffs.


This result hurt us a lot more than the Stains one though.

I chuffing love you Taylor.

He's spot on.