Feilden no where near as consistent as peacock, therefore not in same overall class, at one time yes now no sorry.

Except this season in SL that's not the case, either in performances, or in stats evaluation. Plus JP's only managed to make 17 appearances, staying injury free actually does matter.

Except that he is as consistent, more so in fact as Fielden has played the whole season to a top standard.

It is strange, fans of others teams are trying to tell us how bad his hands are, and how he is not as good/consistent as other players. yet looking at our player of the season (id say its a pretty good system, all the fans giving the top 3 players from each game, with the top 5 each game getting points) and Fielden is top of that this season. so in theory he has been our most consistent player this season, and we have finished top of the table. surely that means he is a pretty decent player.