Please show us your facts that prove Roberts is over rated

People are dubbing him a 'superstar' when he's done naff all apart from have 2 bad games. I know you can't go off 2 games when judging a player usually but he really has been that bad I can't see him improving... people went off less when we signed Coley. Most of peoples opinions are based on what they want to happen rather than facts on here.

First Tim Smith was much better v Hull than Wakey. I just wish people would stop harping on about his Rookie of the year awards. When he won that his coach Brian Smith said he would play for Australia within 2 years. It never happened. If it had Tim would not be at Wigan. The player we have is still a good one but a pale shadow of what he could have been due to his ongoing health issues.

Have a drink on the season ticket holders boys!

Shock Horror they aren't having a drink are they? How dare they?

So you dont have any facts to prove hes over rated then

your going of a players first 2 games in months and months..read up his try scoring record in the best league in the world and you will see hes far from over rated.

I'd be fairly worried about Smith drinking, wasn't it a major contributory factor in making his bi polar disorder worse?

And you're kidding yourselves over Pryce, he'll never be a susperstar for you or anyone else.

Is Riddell drinking water there? I guess it could be vodka though. Either way you cant expect them not to drink all season. I'd only be bothered if it was the day before a game or when they're supposed to be at training.

The most shocking thing about those pics is that they're in Jumpin Jaks.