From a Wigan point of view maybe but Ian millward had massive impact on super league as his record proves.

I like maguire tho, it's obvious he's a great coach and gets what he wants from his players. Wigan under maguire are a very well drilled team.

Millward is a turd who inherited an excellent team. Maguire transformed a team of nearly men and made them champions within 12 months with only one signing too, a year later and 3 more signings he's made them cup kings!

Millward isn't fit to be named in the same category.

Clearly a very good coach - I'm looking forward to seeing how Souths get on next year.

Are you saying your team isn't excellent then? Because Millward did to Saints exactly what Maguire has done to Wigan and then Anderson topped it off by strengthening the defence, turning the team into a quadruple winning side.

And we won the Cup under Millward too, as well as the Championship. I think we did the double under him one year as well.


As Maguire? You don't like him because of 75-0 (preceeded by 70-0 if memory serves).

How do you suggest we compare them?

He must be the most talented coach Wigan have had. To turn them round so quickly is sensational. This time last year we had won nothing for years. We now currently hold all 3 British trophies at the same time.

Doesn't that have a nice ring to it!?!

But does that mean he's had the biggest impact on super league?

Maybe some fans are still on a massive high of winning the cc and still posting based on that.

Don't get me wrong, MM is a top class coach and I like the bloke. I'd have him at saints without a shadow of a doubt (swap you for Royce? ) but to say he's the best coach in the world and to say he's the best coach to happen to super league IMO is a little ott.

In regards to Madge versus Millward. Madge is now returning to the NRL to a head coaching position, something Millward was never able to achieve without getting it by default and then failing miserably at it.

Personally I think Madge is the best coach to grace SL and as debatable as that maybe, if he manages to turn around South Sydney like he did Wigan. Then it will for me go along way to proving he's the best coach SL's ever had. We shall wait and see.

Millward turned down St george to stay at saints.

Because he knows hes not good enough for the NRL. Hes not even good enough for Super League anymore.

Lack of ambition?

Easier to stay at Saints where the going was good rather than really test himself?

Don't get me wrong I'm sad Madge is leaving, but perhaps he's taken us as far as he feels he can. He's brought us back to the top in the process winning every domestic trophy on offer. And now wants to test himself in biggest and toughest comp in the world. Credit to the guy!

Maybe he's not good enough now but at the time he was. Milkweeds problem was he got to big for his boots and thought he was bigger than the club.